A few other people have mentioned Danskos. They do make waterproof shoes that are labeled as such. They also make patent ones that wipe up easily and are super cute; they’re essentially waterproof. If you look around you can find them on sale for less than $100.

Nothing leather or sneaker like will stand up to water or other fluids getting inside the shoe, unless you go with Crocs or similar.

Finally, if you want to spend coin on a good pair of GoreTex shoes, I LOVE my Salomons.