Gatorae t1_jbmwzur wrote on March 10, 2023 at 4:36 AM

Reply to comment by mrsmeesiecks in Guys, ROTHY’S! They don’t have a lifetime guarantee, but I’ve had this pair 6 years and look at them! These were an absolute muddy mess before I threw them in the washer. Bonus, they are even comfortable. by mrsmeesiecks

I'm a 9 in every other brand. This style, I cant wear the 9s, my poor toes are squished so, so painfully. A 10 would probably work but it's very frustrating to so badly missize an online brand.

mrsmeesiecks OP t1_jbn5f8w wrote on March 10, 2023 at 6:03 AM

I have a 9.5 and every now and then do wish I would’ve opted for a 10, good call. I agree, I don’t understand how they are so consistently off one size

Inkdrunnergirl t1_jbovokg wrote on March 10, 2023 at 4:26 PM

They have an awesome return/exchange, when I got my first pair I only did half size, I went online to do the exchange and dropped them off and the exchange pair shipped as soon as they scanned it in. I think it was a specific FedEx location

aztecannie99 t1_jbp0b7c wrote on March 10, 2023 at 4:55 PM

Yes their sizing is insane. I am a 9.5 wide so my first few pairs (including points) are a 10.5. I really should’ve bought 11s or 11.5 in the points. I have settled that in the future with the flats that the 11 does fit me better. I actually prefer the flat to the point tbh. I have one pair of 11 flats. I would sell my 10.5s but they haven’t re released what I want to replace the smaller ones with yet (red camo, copper, and Python fig) and probably won’t. Bummer.