Comments

You must log in or register to comment.

meowmiixx t1_jbnuis5 wrote

I want to try them but I don’t wear anything without arch support.

59

Used_Ad_7409 t1_jboon2g wrote

Because of this I now wear Allbirds. Much more support and the same ability to throw in the washer etc.

21

Current_Addition_582 t1_jbr5fh3 wrote

I tried allbirds because rothys don’t ship to Australia anymore, and I can’t stand them!!! They are about to go to the charity store, I wore them once and they felt all slippery and weird.

Now have three pairs of rothy’s that I got second hand, they are absolutely the best shoe I’ve ever worn.

2

learned_jibe t1_jboaxyq wrote

I have them and barely wear them for exactly this reason. They make nice travel slippers, though.

14

Inkdrunnergirl t1_jbovbwx wrote

You can add insoles with arch support, just take out the Rothy’s ones

7

tunisia3507 t1_jbqids3 wrote

Most people wear far more arch support than they actually need. Sure, some people have deformities which make it necessary, but a lot of people just have weak feet and wear increasingly built-up shoes as a crutch, further crippling themselves.

4

meowmiixx t1_jbqjldl wrote

I can’t speak to others but I naturally have very high arches

3

Necessary_Tie_1731 t1_jbqm9nz wrote

It doesnt have to do with the size of your arches. Whether they are weak or collapsed.

1

smollmollss t1_jbqqavk wrote

really? i'm actually genuinely curious about this. i wear ultraboost dna for the support and they're so comfortable but most ballet flats with nothing in them hurt my feet if i wear them more than an hour

2

aztecannie99 t1_jbozmyo wrote

If you buy them a size to size and half to big (two sizes up for points) you can add insoles to them. I like the Vionic 3/4 insole.

I wish the Allbirds looked good on my feet. I have heard good things about the Allbirds insoles as well but haven’t tried them.

3

meowmiixx t1_jbqk2pz wrote

A few people suggested this but I feel like Rothy’s already has a high price tag. If I’m spending money on something I want it to work out of the box. Maybe if I try them on irl and they look amazing on me I could be swayed but I won’t bet on it.

Edit: I’m comparing the price to all birds

4

mrsmeesiecks OP t1_jbmqu6x wrote

If I persuade anyone to get a pair, you should know that the sizing runs 1 size small, so size up. Also, they will make your feet smell terrible even if you don’t have smelly feet. I suggest buying ballet socks!

Edit- You definitely need an entire size up

36

Gatorae t1_jbmwzur wrote

I'm a 9 in every other brand. This style, I cant wear the 9s, my poor toes are squished so, so painfully. A 10 would probably work but it's very frustrating to so badly missize an online brand.

18

mrsmeesiecks OP t1_jbn5f8w wrote

I have a 9.5 and every now and then do wish I would’ve opted for a 10, good call. I agree, I don’t understand how they are so consistently off one size

3

Inkdrunnergirl t1_jbovokg wrote

They have an awesome return/exchange, when I got my first pair I only did half size, I went online to do the exchange and dropped them off and the exchange pair shipped as soon as they scanned it in. I think it was a specific FedEx location

1

aztecannie99 t1_jbp0b7c wrote

Yes their sizing is insane. I am a 9.5 wide so my first few pairs (including points) are a 10.5. I really should’ve bought 11s or 11.5 in the points. I have settled that in the future with the flats that the 11 does fit me better. I actually prefer the flat to the point tbh. I have one pair of 11 flats. I would sell my 10.5s but they haven’t re released what I want to replace the smaller ones with yet (red camo, copper, and Python fig) and probably won’t. Bummer.

1

Lou_C_Fer t1_jbn7jcx wrote

If you want a cure... before you put them on, use hand sanitizer on your feet. My vibrams used to smell like death. Then I read about the hand sanitizer trick, and the smell is like 80 to 90 percent gone.

16

mrsmeesiecks OP t1_jbn89p8 wrote

Ugh my gosh, Vibrams. I kept my pair outside. That’s bonkers though, hand sanitizer! I wonder if rubbing alcohol would work the same, you can use it as deodorant in a pinch

6

ian9outof10 t1_jbqhuw5 wrote

I used to use rubbing alcohol on my shoes, it absolutely does work although it gives them a slightly different whiff - but it’s not obnoxious.

1

WH_Laundry_Cart t1_jbok24v wrote

This is because the alcohol kills the bacteria on your skin from the sweat that actually causes the stink.

This ideation can also be used on your underarms. I keep a small spray bottle with alcohol in it that I spray on my pits and lightly dab off. This basically kills the stink. I then apply my deodorant. Mama don't have no stinky pits no more.

1

curiosity0425 t1_jbmzmzc wrote

They're made out of recycled plastic, right? I'm so afraid of sweaty feet for that reason

5

mrsmeesiecks OP t1_jbn5ovo wrote

Sure enough, I forgot about that. Definitely explains the smell problem, they do make my feet sweaty. Worth it tho!

4

fubar6 t1_jbnxkbg wrote

I bought a beautiful pair for my wife and she wants to love them, but can't. She gets blisters. You think this is due to size issue alone? I'd hate to spring for another, larger pair, with the same results. Did the smaller ones give you blisters by any chance?

3

mrsmeesiecks OP t1_jbpdjxs wrote

I wish I could say, I only bought the bigger size. I also bought them used (don’t judge) so I may have never had issues because someone else broke them in for me

1

fubar6 t1_jbporyt wrote

Ohh I will judge. How dare you buy an item that's made out of recycled plastic second-hand?! I'm all for it!! Thanks for the info.. perhaps someone experienced the blisters and will let me know.

1

mrsmeesiecks OP t1_jbqyq26 wrote

Haha that’s a much better way to look at it! Buying shoes secondhand feels like it’s probably gross to most people, I know my mom judges me haha

And you know they will

1

PageStunning6265 t1_jbocu91 wrote

Thanks for this, that’s what I was coming to ask. I’m a size where 5.5 is too small and 6 is too big and never in my life would it have occurred to me to order a 7, so I appreciate the heads up.

1

mrsmeesiecks OP t1_jbqzacq wrote

Other people have also said that the chart online is accurate, so that may help find the best size too!

2

Flat_Violinist_8232 t1_jbqnt6a wrote

I have 7 pairs currently and you just persuaded me to buy more.

My oldest pair is 5 years now and I wear those the most. They look impeccable even after all this time.

1

agirlwithoutahome t1_jbo4xn9 wrote

I have a pair and I wish I loved them!! :( they are sooo uncomfortable on my feet and rubbed my feet so horribly that I could never wear them again

13

mrsmeesiecks OP t1_jbpd6a3 wrote

That really sucks! I have my grandma’s big, wide feet and they never caused me issue, although I did have to size up

3

Dexterdacerealkilla t1_jbs5q5n wrote

Do you ever actually buy wide shoes? Just trying to gauge how wide you mean when you say it.

3

mrsmeesiecks OP t1_jbtpodb wrote

I do when I can! As an idea- I can’t wear any high top converse without my pinkie toes going numb and my feet normally spill over any flip flops at least a little. Gladiators are tough too

2

Dexterdacerealkilla t1_jbuswny wrote

I’m definitely in the same boat. For flip flops, I do have a recommendation though! Sanuk Yoga Joy are by far the most comfortable flip flops I’ve ever bought.

1

mrsmeesiecks OP t1_jc0ghc4 wrote

I’ll look into it! Not like I need too much of a push to buy new shoes haha, thanks for the rec!

1

Perfect-Agent-2259 t1_jbpw394 wrote

I had this happen, too!! I had bought a pair in my "normal" size, and they "mostly" fit, but rubbed the wrong way. I thought they would stretch because they are knit. They did NOT stretch.

Bought a second pair half a size up and they are great and I adore them.

2

Kate-HW-Bush t1_jbujxqp wrote

I found odor eaters insoles to be basically necessary with these. Even washing the normal insole just didn’t work for me as I’m pretty picky about body odor lol. They are a lot softer too as a bonus, I know what you mean about the abrasion especially when it’s hot.

1

literallymoist t1_jbn4abn wrote

I finally wore my main work pair down after years of frequent wear. Been melting away the frizzy spots that crop up where they get scuffed with a lighter, but starting to just look ragged.

Far and away still the best shoes anyway. I just wish they had more support.

11

mrsmeesiecks OP t1_jbn5tg8 wrote

That’s a fantastic tip, mine will start going someday! I do agree on the support. I love the way they look and feel, but they have about as much arch support as Vans and Toms

2

literallymoist t1_jbn6ez1 wrote

I may try shoving an insole inside one of these days.

If you're going to try the lighter thing, pass the flame under it VERY briefly, and go over the spot a couple times if once isn't enough to clean up the frizzies. If you hold it still I imagine it will burn quickly.

3

mrsmeesiecks OP t1_jbn7sbq wrote

I have before, it makes them a liiiittle tight, but it’s probably a price worth paying.

Not a mistake I’d want to learn on my own lol, thanks!

1

pruche t1_jbo0n3c wrote

What are those

Genuinely asking this is not a meme

4

MacbookOnFire t1_jbo3hku wrote

I think like hard socks or something

6

bilb0baggns t1_jbor8ma wrote

No they are slip on shoes. This pair has the insoles removed so they can be washed.

2

anne_marie718 t1_jbnmns2 wrote

Same! The soles of mine still look brand new, and I bought them in maybe 2019. to be fair, I worked from home for 2 years in there so they didn’t get a lot of use, but I’ve worn them every work day otherwise. And I used to take public transit and have a bit of a hike to get to my office once I got off the train.

2

HestiaAC t1_jbo755o wrote

I have the exact same pair. They're extremely painful. I wore these on a dinner date with my husband and we hit up an outlet mall after- I had to buy flip flops on the date and swap them out just so we could keep walking around, I was so miserable.

2

Endor-Fins t1_jboex7d wrote

I have a pair of bright red Points as well and I live in them. So comfortable and chic yet practical. Can’t wait to thrift another pair!

2

Empty_Tumbleweed4525 t1_jbois57 wrote

I have one and actually don’t find them comfortable if wearing them for a whole day. The fabric rubs into my skin too.

2

blacklike-death t1_jbolf0s wrote

I bought a pair last year and immediately returned them! The heel part is too small and I was stepping partially on the thick seam. I was prepared to buy inserts too. Love the look but poor design

2

OohLaLapin t1_jbnpm3a wrote

Their sizing guide helps a ton to get the size right the first time, I will note.

1

OdderGiant t1_jbnw88x wrote

The men’s sneakers are outstanding, too.

1

ser_pez t1_jbolujd wrote

I love mine. I just got a pear of the driving loafers and they’re even better.

1

crazybutnotnuts t1_jbop48g wrote

Do you think the black color helped with longevity? I’m looking for a new work shoe and curious if lighter colors would last as long!

1

mrsmeesiecks OP t1_jc0grfi wrote

Ya know, probably so.

But they are so easy to clean, maybe you’d be safe with any color that isn’t white!

2

Inkdrunnergirl t1_jbov9eh wrote

I looooooove my Rothy’s! They are also made from recycled materials. I have several pairs, they make great work/travel shoes

1

aztecannie99 t1_jbozeaq wrote

Yes you can wash them but hope they don’t shrink. I washed my favorite pair (red camo points) and they shrunk the tiniest bit. Washed on cold and hang dried. I was soo bummed. At least if you have to replace yours they are black and they keep those all the time.

1

mrsmeesiecks OP t1_jc0gy06 wrote

Mine feel slightly tighter after I wash them, but always loosen up on the first wear. I also just get a washcloth and wipe them down instead of washing them too much

1

delightfullytangy t1_jbph0xa wrote

Agreed! I have two pairs that I have been wearing for at least 5 years. They still look brand new.

1

EngineerPelia t1_jbqbau4 wrote

LOVE my Rothy’s. I wouldn’t wear them for a ton of walking due to the arch support issue, but that still makes them appropriate for so many events.

1

Squeezycatjet t1_jbr1b2a wrote

I wonder if they would work for wide feet

1

mrsmeesiecks OP t1_jc0h2wz wrote

I have wide feet and they are okay for me, but DEFINITELY size up

2

FriendshipMaine t1_jbrio4u wrote

Unfortunately they are foot coffins. If the toes can’t splay, you’re on your way to poor postural & movement habits, and possibly even bunions and more.

1