I've had a men's pair of Thursday's for around 6 years I think? I've worn them a ton, especially when I used to have a 3 mile roundtrip walking commute. Resoled once and they're super comfortable. Not sure how the sole durability compares to other brands but the leather uppers have held up really well even with occasional abuse on wet/snowy days. They wear in really well. I did have a friend who bought a second pair more recently and wasn't as impressed with the quality but I can't speak to that either.