My husband has the men's version of this coat https://www.vermontcountrystore.com/womens-original-vermont-barn-coat/product/72332 . He's had it for I think 5 years and has been happy with it. But it rarely drops below freezing where we live. Recently I noticed one small hole I need to mend. And once he snagged and ripped the pocket seam, so I re sewed that.