Looking for high quality women’s black leather mid heel ankle boots to replace old cheap pair

Submitted by aidilk t3_yqq318 in BuyItForLife

So have loved these leather Sam Edelman Joey boots, they’re comfortable , have a 5.5” shaft height that hits my leg at the right spot, a not too tall 2.5” heel, and a semi pointed almond toe that is flattering without making my feet look too long. They were cheap and they lasted several seasons but have reached the end of their life and started peeling . I bought them a long time ago not wanting to invest in super high quality boots yet because I know it will be $$$ and wasn’t sure if I’d love the style for a long time- turns out I still really love them so I’m ready to pull the trigger on a nicer pair. I live in Florida so warmth isn’t a big issue - just looking for quality leather that won’t peel after a few years like these . Anyone have any boots in a similar style that they love? Hoping to spend under $500. Bonus if they can be re-soled because obviously that makes them more BIFL but not a must.

18

Comments

You must log in or register to comment.

Stray_Alleycat t1_ivquryu wrote

La canadienne. High quality boots made in Canada. Waterproof leather and super comfy!

7

edcculus t1_ivppi42 wrote

Check out Nisolo.

6

bullshead125 t1_ivpquer wrote

Yes, I was going to say the Dari boot from Nisolo. I think they are waterproof too, which is a nice feature.

3

Fmarulezkd t1_ivr1z9o wrote

All conditioned leather - which is a requirement to be for life- is waterproof.

3

bullshead125 t1_ivru6w1 wrote

Wish Frye would add that to their lineup then. My friend worked for them for a decade and would always warn me not to get them (any of my many pairs) wet because Frye wouldn’t stand behind any warranty or repair if you did.

1

quiltsterhamster_254 t1_ivpq797 wrote

Check out Thursday boot company

​

Soho Zip looks like the closest to your existing pair https://thursdayboots.com/products/womens-soho-high-heel-zip-up-boot-black

3

aidilk OP t1_ivrcbox wrote

Thanks. The Tempo is looking pretty nice . I’ve seen ads for this company but hadn’t heard any real reviews concerning the quality

2

lvupquokka t1_ivqev7o wrote

Those flat soles though, look so slippery.

1

2ndfloorbalcony t1_ivpsxmu wrote

I like RM Williams Cuban heal boots. Expensive but lasts many many years. My aunts pair are in their 3rd decade. They have a great custom program that would allow you to have the side zip if you don’t love the Chelsea boot style.

3

aidilk OP t1_ivsayfc wrote

They’ve got some beautiful Chelseas. It’s making me want to save up to upgrade a few other pairs of boots !

3

walter_toblers_ghost t1_ivr6s43 wrote

I bought the Italian Leather Chelsea Boot in black by Everlane last year and they are soooo amazing. No break in time, buttery leather, snug around the ankles. I’ve worn them almost every day to work all winter and they’re holding up excellent.

3

aidilk OP t1_ivrbw0x wrote

Was eyeing the city boot but it’s all sold out in most sizes . Good to know the leather holds up ! Thanks

2

IMHOcomments t1_iw4y4y3 wrote

You can find Everlane on resale sites like Poshmark. I know that is hard if you don’t know you’ll like it but if you find them at a good deal and they don’t work you can sell them.

1

klmbkvist t1_ivqagrs wrote

Red Wing Women's Harriet. These are not exactly what you wanted, but sorta close.

Red Wing Women's collection.

2

aidilk OP t1_ivsabdb wrote

Definitely look quality enough, just wish the whole boot was black !

3

pancakelady t1_ivwze8p wrote

I was going to recommend these as well, got the chunky heel pair over 5 years ago, still going strong with conditioning every 6 months

Edited to add, you can definitely use a shoe cream to darken the brown, mine have darkened anyway over the years. I ended up getting another pair of flat chelsea boots, iron rangers and the oxfords as well. All superb quality and with recraftable soles. You can also check out r/goodyearwelt for some extra insight on good boots. Good luck!

1

pontoponyo t1_ivqoz0h wrote

Blundstone has some nice dress boots. I have a pair of their Chelsea boots. They’re 6 years old and still look brand new. Might not be an exact match, but I can attest to the quality.

2

pontoponyo t1_ivqp8o8 wrote

The #1960 and #1671 heels are close to what you’re looking for.

3

ButterIsMyFriend t1_ivqz4zo wrote

These are great boots but I wouldn’t consider them to be the dress style OP posted

1

aidilk OP t1_ivrbsj4 wrote

Yes I definitely love the look of Blundstones for an everyday utility boot but looking for something more sleek and dressy

1

grumpycat92 t1_ivrr76s wrote

I have a pair of Artica boots. I have not had them for life, but I’ve worn them in snow for three winters (including salt, mud, etc) and they still look and feel brand new. Real leather and water proof too.

2

aidilk OP t1_ivrws83 wrote

Ooh the Artica France boots look beautiful

2

grumpycat92 t1_ivudv3i wrote

Yes! I use a leather conditioner/protector before exposing them to the elements and regularly throughout the winter (maybe once a month). Then one final coat at the end of the season before they’re put in storage :)

1

kweeket t1_ixajiw2 wrote

Can you recommend a good leather conditioner?

1

grumpycat92 t1_ixay56h wrote

Depending on where you live, I honestly just use the Aldo one. It’s cheap but I’ve used it for 15 years and never been disappointed! Aldo Water Resistant Lotion. Sold out right now but I’m sure they’ll restock very soon.

1

pricklypear91 t1_ivv893f wrote

If you want boots that can be re-soled, check out r/goodyearwelt.

2

glassteelhammer t1_iw2xriw wrote

https://as98.net/

My lady has owned nothing but these for as long as I've known her.

She still has the pair she was wearing the day I met her.

1

5spd4wd t1_ivplik5 wrote

Macy's is having a Black Friday sale (even though today is Wednesday). There seems to be a lot of women's boots to choose from.

Then there is DSW (Designer Shoe Warehouse) that has this ad on its site: Last Day (!) 30% Off Boots

−4