Viewing a single comment thread. View all comments

Freed_lab_rat t1_ixxa7b9 wrote

Transmission fluid is for automatics, not manual gearboxes.

−1

sponge_welder t1_ixxsuxa wrote

There's definitely manual transmission fluid, it's much less specialized than ATF, but MTF certainly exists. Honda recommends changing it every 30-60k miles

2

F-21 t1_ixxy0jo wrote

Manual gearboxes in nearly all instances use SAE 90 api gl-5 or gl-4 oil. You don't need to ever swap it out.

ATF is something totally different.

1

sponge_welder t1_ixy2zk0 wrote

I don't think you're going to find many supporters of sealed transmissions and lifetime fluids in the buy it for life subreddit, it's not a very long term solution, and it certainly doesn't apply to every manual transmission

And I'm specifying ATF and MTF because I'm used to Hondas, and Honda has a specific Manual Transmission Fluid. I know that it's not the same thing as ATF and that not all manufacturers have a specific manual transmission fluid

1

F-21 t1_ixy4lr9 wrote

That's just how it is, my 1997 Land Cruiser had the same fluid in the gearbox until ~300000km last year when I changed it the first time, which is beyond the mileage where most cars around here get discarded.

It does not make it any worse.

Like with this grease, some guy even said it should be swapped yearly. You're not doing anything good by that - if anything you're most likely to harm something like strip threads to some panel or whatever. Gears don't require a lot of lube anyway, it's probably more important for the bearings that drive them.

These kitchen aid mixers also probably use sealed bearings in the electric motor and most people don't think about repacking those with grease.

1