I have a Lodge and can vouch for their warranty. I bought one off of Amazon Warehouse like 12 years ago for $25 (back when Amazon Warehouse was decent, not just broken returned stuff). About 3-4 years in, the enamel on the bottom started bubbling up. I decided what the heck and emailed their warranty dept. A few pictures and emails later and I had a band new one on the way! Lodge earned themselves a loyal customer that day. The one they sent it still going strong with regular use.