Viewing a single comment thread. View all comments

vishnusnavel87 t1_iwx6i8f wrote

It was Sally’s as a kid. When Flo died it all seemed to change, then they sold the business. These days it’s Modern. Ernie’s as a 2nd. Bar has a good pie, some of my friends were the pizza makers there for years. I can’t get behind Pepe’s much anymore. Roseland in the Valley used to be one of the best around, I don’t know what happened. It seems like when the old folks retire & die off it really effects the quality of the pizza.


Bookofdrewsus t1_iwx77vg wrote

With you on Pepe’s. Overrated a bit. Modern might be the best. Mondo in Middletown is nice too, mainly because I live close to it.