Viewing a single comment thread. View all comments

Jean-Porte t1_itv3yxu wrote

Did the author offer you something ?

25

master3243 t1_itwsc56 wrote

It might also be informative to know what were the details of the communication? No matter what, it's wrong and I believe the paper should be rejected. But the repercussions for the reviewer might depend on the intentions which should be inferable from the details of the communication.

5