Viewing a single comment thread. View all comments

EnvironmentalBar338 t1_itvo79j wrote

Reply to comment by ID4gotten in [D]Cheating in AAAI 2023 rebuttal by [deleted]

I emailed the chairs anonymously. I did not reveal the author's name. Just hope that they can rethink/modify this anonymity policy in the future.

They replied "thank you".

19

pm_me_your_smth t1_itw7kso wrote

> I did not reveal the author's name

Shouldn't that paper be voided because of the incident? Since it's clear that anonymity is compromised which is critical for the review process.

28

listenener t1_itw4t2w wrote

Good job. Nothing will happen because you didn't reveal the author's name.

12

ID4gotten t1_itx0mrn wrote

Sorry you didn't get a more definitive or satisfactory result. Up to you how much to continue to push it, but you could let them know you'll think twice about reviewing for them in the future without anonymity. You can also reject papers from people you know or have any link to (possibly harder).

1