HermanCainsGhost t1_iuz7dxs wrote
Reply to comment by nomadiclizard in [D] DALL·E to be made available as API, OpenAI to give users full ownership rights to generated images by TiredOldCrow
> When anyone else, using the same prompt, gets the same image?
That's... not how DALL-E works? Like you can use the exact same prompt and you'll get different images each time
World177 t1_iuzgmpa wrote
Using the same seed, you'll get the the same image with the same prompt. Either way, they're both partially a generalization of what those words represent.
> When anyone else, using the same prompt, gets the same image?
Though, to answer them, legal copyright is concerned with human creative effort. Choosing novel and interesting inputs for a final art piece is somewhat comparable to choosing a gradient when using photoshop. The legal copyright being enforceable will likely be on if the court determines enough creative effort went into creating the image.
In the following video a copyright lawyer on YouTube (Lawful Masses) covers the spectrum of fair use and copyright ownership. I think this video provides a insight into how a the legal system might also determine if someone owns copyright to AI generated art. They also recently covered AI generated art in another video, but I think the first video better explains how law isn't simple binary choices.
_poisonedrationality t1_iv0txbb wrote
Does DALL-E let you choose the seed?
Western-Hawk4469 t1_iv2sj1q wrote
why do u guys keep say u get the same image with the same prompt? i get a feeling u hav not even tried it out? i have never got the same result ever!
bankimu t1_iuzec0s wrote
Unless you happen to use the same seed.
Viewing a single comment thread. View all comments