Viewing a single comment thread. View all comments

Sufficient_Flight876 t1_iv3jb5i wrote

8, 3, and 3. First time submitting a ML conference and I'm curious if reviewers can update their score freely during the discussion or they can only update once at the end

4

Blasphemer666 t1_iv3l3oc wrote

I am also quite curious, my sum is the same as yours (5,6, and 3).
But I have no high score, idk how to read these scores correctly.

So how do they decide what papers are accepted after final scores are out?
Average > 5.0?

1

khaldrug0 t1_iv4ou32 wrote

I think it's decided by the area chair, they read your paper and the reviews, then they decide whether to accept or reject

2

deschaussures147 t1_iv3m4yz wrote

They can do that freely during the reviewing period, but if you want an honest answer I won't put too much hope into the submission with your current score :D

1

tfburns t1_iv3mvh5 wrote

>8, 3, and 3

Very big split! In one past case of mine, I found the higher-rated one sneaked their rating down to go along with the group without saying anything. Hope that doesn't happen for you.

>I'm curious if reviewers can update their score freely during the discussion or they can only update once at the end

AFAIK they can change at any time by "editing" their original review comment. Ideally they also add some text/reply to indicate that they changed their score and why.

Whatever the outcome, congrats on your first submission!

1

Sufficient_Flight876 t1_iv3phf8 wrote

>AFAIK

Thank you all! Yeah I'll try my best for the rebuttal since reviewers at least liked the method... They complained the writing and some of the validation

2