Viewing a single comment thread. View all comments

tfburns t1_iv3n3s5 wrote

Reply to comment by big_mantis in [D] ICLR 2023 reviews are out. How was your experience ? by dasayan05

>2 8s and 3 3s

For a total of 5 reviews? Not only a big split but also a large number (both of my submissions only have 3 reviews, and average across all papers is apparently 4.1 at present).

Congrats on your first submission :)

9

51616 t1_iv45ny4 wrote

Having 5 reviews i suppose is unusual. I guess initially the paper has 8/8/3/3 split, which might necessitate an additional review. Unfortunately, that one is another 3

6

big_mantis t1_iv4fr2l wrote

Thanks! Yeah I was a little salty we got 5 lol, the average would've been a lot better without that extra 3

3