Viewing a single comment thread. View all comments

calvinreeve t1_ivbaqh3 wrote

56815 with confidence 23224. Reviewer with score 1 claims to not know the area and that the paper is not understandable to "general experts". Is the fact we have 5 reviews an indication that the confused reviewer's comments will be discarded?

2

cwkx t1_ivja2s8 wrote

If the 1 says they don't know the area (especially if it's a short review), most AC's will discard that rating.

1