Viewing a single comment thread. View all comments

oldppd t1_ivpm54o wrote

One reviewer seems positive and summarized that this paper is marginally above the acceptance, but he gave a 5 score. Should I notice him or something? Will this offend him? This is my first time submitting to ICLR, and the score is 6, 5, 5, 5. So this question is indeed important for me. Is there anyone experienced who can tell me about it? Thanks!

1

East-Beginning9987 t1_ivss7mr wrote

no one is offended by anything I believe, if it's a valid and polite response. The alternative is to accept rejection, which I don't thing you would like

1

oldppd t1_ivt702h wrote

>no one is offended by anything I believe, if it's a valid and polite response. The alternative is to accept rejection, which I don't thing you would like

Thanks for your suggestion. I decide to add the notice of this in the end of the reply.

2