Viewing a single comment thread. View all comments

maybelator t1_ixc8f5q wrote

Reply to comment by Simping4Kaiming in [D] AISTATS 2023 reviews are out by von_oldmann

100% depends on your rebuttal. Show that you understood the low reviews and improved your paper in consequence. Or if a bad review is nonsensical make it clear with line ref and citations.

2

Simping4Kaiming t1_ixchk1c wrote

Thanks, how is the usual average ?

1

maybelator t1_ixcyhrp wrote

Papers are not selected based on their average, but wether or bot there is a consensus towards acceptance. Show the meta reviewers that you can meaningfully address the reservations of the 4 and 5, or show that they are not valid (be very careful with this route).

Based on the scores, the scale tips in your favor. But the rebuttal will be critical.

1