Viewing a single comment thread. View all comments

w0lph t1_j0el9zd wrote

Curious to know how you do step 4.

Also, I think it’s a dangerous use case. I don’t think you will ever eliminate the risk of hallucinations, and that can be catastrophic when it comes to health.

55

Nowado t1_j0fdi2f wrote

As much as I would like to agree, all (even sensitive and important, like health) use cases have to be compared against realistic alternative. Currently this alternative is google/webMD and previously it was asking friends/guessing. Not doctors.

Adding disclaimer not to treat this as a medical advice for legal reasons however would of course be good call for OP personally.

20

Seon9 t1_j0foo1j wrote

I think it's worse than Google or WebMD because people are biased toward believing detailed (richer) information sources, esp if it's masked behind AI. You might receive vague advice from a friend or WebMD but the information is weighted against the source's trustworthiness, perceived soundness, information richness, etc. I think this oversteps alot of that for most people and people might be more inclined to believe it.

It also overlooks that research ≠ clinical practice and that translating research into practice requires numerous hurdles. There can be a decade of research and numerous publication for a drug that then collapses in clinical testing. Or misattribution, that deaths diagnosed from shaken babies syndrome are prob due to prior non-shaking related trauma. I think access to research is a good thing but stripped of context like this isn't.

I also wonder if the hallucinations increase as the pool of information shrinks. Like I'm not gonna use this if I have a common cold but if I have rare S3 colorectal cancer then I might find this useful. Cool project but medical applications are always tough.

16

NotMyMain007 t1_j0i3nwz wrote

I do agree with you, but at the same time, there is some really shitty places on earth, it would be a good option to have instead of just laying on the ground and dying. Even more if this keep evolving.

1