Viewing a single comment thread. View all comments

NoOne3051 OP t1_j0wgdr6 wrote

Reply to comment by karake in [D] AAMAS 2023 Review Discussion by NoOne3051

for this year? 6 says that good paper but won't mind if rejected because of lower acceptance rate.

​

Then probably its a reject for me?

1

karake t1_j0wiyp3 wrote

AAMAS typically has an acceptance rate of about ~25% for full papers and another ~15% including extended abstracts. So it is quite selective. It is possible you get accepted if the meta reviewer really likes the paper (or some of the reviewers increase their scores).

https://www.ifaamas.org/Proceedings/aamas2022/pdfs/welcome.pdf see this from last year.

2

NoOne3051 OP t1_j0wktl0 wrote

Hmm :(. I hope the one with 4 changes his review. He just said my paper lacks theory (its an empirical paper with novel formulations for most part where we adapations of SOTA algorithms.). I hope meta reviewer sees it. There were no other concerns raised by reviewers (very short reviews as compared to ones I get for my other papers at NeurIPS, AAAI)

1