Viewing a single comment thread. View all comments

siebzy t1_j5oeaty wrote

growing up in MA I saw a few roof collapses. Almost all on garages or screened porches.

If it's a pretty small section you're worried about, and you feel like you can get at it safely, I'd go for it.

15

[deleted] OP t1_j5ofgnu wrote

[deleted]

6

hesh582 t1_j5pi8lh wrote

roof raking is really not that bad imo.

you're not actually trying to scrape the roof clean, you're just dislodging some weight. it's fine to do a halfassed job. the position is a lot more comfortable for your back too.

waaay better than shoveling even if it's a pain in the ass to get the roof rake out.

5

marrymejojo t1_j5rwibg wrote

Agreed I do it for a flat section of my roof and it's kind of satisfying to watch all that snow tumble off.

1

lostdad75 t1_j5olrhh wrote

Porch and garage roofs collapse for two reasons; because they tend to be flatter plus they do not have heated living space underneath to help melt the snow

3

siebzy t1_j5plh6u wrote

I would also guess that those types of structures aren't necessarily built with the same level of care or maintained as well as the main house.

2

eljefino t1_j5rdtt9 wrote

When people add porches on they don't want to block the view from the second floor, nor the one from the first. So they need flat-ish roofs.

1

hamakabi t1_j5p3st3 wrote

you can get a lot of snow off the roof by tying a length of paracord around a full water bottle and throwing it over the roof, then pulling the cord to the side. Not nearly as good as a roof rake but it's a lot safer than climbing up there.

3

spatzelface t1_j5rbtp3 wrote

the steeper the pitch, the better off you are. definitely rake the eves as far up as you can reach. i have a ranch and i try to keep at least the lower half of the roof cleared.

2

marrymejojo t1_j5rvnpg wrote

I have a porch like that and I rake the snow off. I dunno if i need to but it makes me feel better.

1