Viewing a single comment thread. View all comments

Jaguars6 t1_j29atxw wrote

Haven’t listened to any except for Smithereens, but I wouldn’t even put it top 100. It sounded like an unfinished demo album to me.

1

BIGTASTYPP t1_j29cfjg wrote

i don’t know why i hear so many people saying this, it’s not unfinished it just doesn’t suck it’s own dick on every song

−2

Jaguars6 t1_j29cytv wrote

Not the production, the actual song structures and ideas. Most of the songs lacked enough substance for me and felt very barren.

3

BIGTASTYPP t1_j2a40vx wrote

It’s not perfect but it does a lot more in 20 minutes than a lot of albums do in an hour+. I think people don’t like it because it’s different.

edit: for the record i’m talking about the song structure and ideas also

0

Jaguars6 t1_j2aeyme wrote

My favorite album of all time is Kid A lol, I love experimental music. It’s just unfinished to me. Didn’t enjoy the musical concepts and lack thereof.

1

kidlaloxxx OP t1_j29bdqv wrote

You didn’t hear 100 albums better stfu

−3

Jaguars6 t1_j29c9ds wrote

The songs didn’t sound fully fleshed out to me like they were half finished or something. Could’ve been a really good album if they were. Not sure why you’re being hostile.

5

kidlaloxxx OP t1_j29cfoe wrote

Cos everyone shitting on my list even tho it’s pretty good

−2

Jaguars6 t1_j29cptw wrote

I’m not shitting on it. I haven’t even heard 4 of them, so couldn’t speak on it. Can’t speak for other redditors, though lol

3

kidlaloxxx OP t1_j29d3v1 wrote

Yea just joined the forum seems like a bunch of degenerate fucks that don’t actually understand music. Just go for the edgy sound that no one knows .

−1

guanwho t1_j2a1kvf wrote

Why do you keep insulting people for having different preferences than you?

2