I've been in all of thems several times while working for the census bureau 2018-2019. Something to remember is that the management changes every few years.

Pavilion has the obvious location benefit to broad st. Their security is okay. At the time their management was "ok". Windows can't open fully so if the AC goes out, you're kind of screwed.

Collonade is legally split into two addresses but they are the same. The management was always very nice to me, but the apartment hallways were absolutely nothing like the lobby. Security was so-so. Same AC situation.

The Addison is okay with a grocery store, pharmacy nearby and it's close'ish to Branch Brook park. There's a bus stop right outside. Management changed three times during my stay. The property was owned by the same company from it's construction until around 2008? Since then it's been sold several times, each time making it more profitable by reducing staff. Security is essentially non existent, and I totally believe they are acting their wage. Tenants tend to vacuum the hallways, but the space you get it great. Also, they have normal windows so you can put window ACs in, if needed. They also have balconies in all 1bd and larger. Management is mid, but if you're nice to them, they do their best to work with you. But they are limited by what the owners setup (a NYC corporation). If you have specified questions about Addison, let me know.