March_Latter t1_iwdvha2 wrote
No would be the shortest answer but i can elaborate.
The scenario you describe has no understanding of human beings or society as a whole. It makes illogical jumps into what an individual may want from the government and people in general.
Overall you could force 100 people to live this way but sooner or later errors and changes would occur and certain people would expect better treatment or better things due to their position in the group. In 100 people there will always be one leader available and seeing no other leader appears to be provided that person will lead a 10% group of followers into taking over the group and elevating the leader and his followers to the ruling class and casting the rest to various degrees of peasantry.
Even the long standing Hippie Communes have discovered that without changing out people regularly and a strict oversight from an outside council that they are overrun within a few years.
So while the thought process that creates this fantasy is meant for good, its really just a case of magical thinking.
Viewing a single comment thread. View all comments