Submitted by radioflea t3_105q9bw in RhodeIsland
Seeking recommendations for the best locally made cookies.
Any location and price point doesn’t matter.
Thanks in advance!
Comments
radioflea OP t1_j3c4xsc wrote
I just read about Castle Hill cookies. I’ve only been to the property once for a wedding many moons ago. Ty for the recommendation!
PigpenMcKernan t1_j3c5lqu wrote
I don’t know if you can buy them at the inn in quantity, but I’m sure you can call and ask. Otherwise, Food Love is also owned by NRG and they always have them there.
TimeSlipperWHOOPS t1_j3c8ff9 wrote
Feed your cheeks in providence does some real decadent stuff
huh_phd t1_j3c9iel wrote
Sweet cakes bakery in Wakefield. I tried every bakery in the state for my wedding, and this place was by far the best
Status_Silver_5114 t1_j3cb2de wrote
I know they are popular but I find them bland and underbaked across the board. Insomnia cookies is equally disappointing.
[deleted] t1_j3ce7w6 wrote
[deleted]
mountain_pose t1_j3chhs1 wrote
clover! at the saturday pvd farm fresh market! best chocolate chip cookies in the state!
Koalify t1_j3ciq8z wrote
Cookie chow at different live events, best cookies ever
TimeSlipperWHOOPS t1_j3cl8gy wrote
Agreed on insomnia! Feed is trying to get the big intense Levain style cookie and they might be the only option around 🤷♂️ If you don't feel like baking that is!
goulio t1_j3cqext wrote
Many don’t know it but Gregg’s makes amazing chocolate chip cookies. Thick and chewy.
Sopressata t1_j3cste8 wrote
Celebrated! When they open back up they’re the BEST.
Worried-Hedgehog3405 t1_j3cx0r0 wrote
Thrive Cakery
skippyspk t1_j3d5g4n wrote
The best cookies at 2:00 am are at Insomnia on Weybosset and possibly Thayer if they’re still there because their cookies are fantastic.
Loveroffinerthings t1_j3dd604 wrote
Loooooove them
Aggravating-Sport359 t1_j3f0djw wrote
This is what I came here to say. Especially the birthday cake flavor
JackNapier85 t1_j3fp8rz wrote
They were really good when they first opened but it's gone down in quality a lot over the last year. They've become extremely doughy in the middle to the point that I can't even eat half of one without feeling gross for eating very mushy doughy cookie. Service has been pretty bad too ever since they opened up the new store. Wife went into the OG location looking for the new December flavors. Girl behind the counter had no idea about the Gingerbread or Hot Cocoa. Wife asked if the new location had them and she just said I don't know and didn't offer to call the new store. Legit didn't say anything else to my wife, looked at her and my wife just said ok and walked out.
Longjumping_Tennis46 t1_j3jhrfn wrote
The chocolate chip cookies at Madrid in Wayland Square. They also make a parfait with chocolate chip cookies and their chocolate mousse if you really want to go all out!
[deleted] t1_j3rp4k3 wrote
Wildflour in Pawtucket makes a good cookie.
PigpenMcKernan t1_j3c4q6v wrote
Castle Hill Cookies from Food Love Market in Middletown (and Castle Hill in Newport)