Viewing a single comment thread. View all comments

Tietonz t1_ixtoskx wrote

Reply to comment by CocodaMonkey in 22-year-old rescue pup is crowned the oldest living dog on Earth by Guinness World Records by spiritoffff

>So? Do you have an example of where that's a problem?

It's not a problem because world records don't really mean anything tangible and they've always been irrelevant, only mattering to people who decide they matter. Which is fine.

It does mean Guinness as a record holding company is illegitimate and any discussion about them should be brought up with that caveat.

1

CocodaMonkey t1_ixv03ax wrote

Your statement doesn't make any logical sense. Listing records you don't care about in no way makes them an illegitimate record holding company. The records they hold are all real and they try to validate them. That's really all anyone wants from a record holding company.

1