Highly recommend Volturno; they also have amazing homemade pasta and other entrees. All around a fantastic restaurant. They actually host pasta making classes in their function room--if you wanted to do something a bit more interactive they might be open to doing a class for just your party. When I did one a few years ago it was very low-key and you got to eat what you made (among lots of other foods and lots of wine flowing). Could be a fun idea, I know my wife would love that.