Submitted by Speterius t3_10ea1ng in askscience
Speterius OP t1_j4rgooc wrote
Reply to comment by taphead739 in Why does the existence of magnetic monopoles imply quantized electric charges? by Speterius
Thank you for the answer. Super insightful.
> "Since quantum mechanics dictates that angular momentum must be quantized, (....)"
Is the fact that angular momentum must be quantized a postulate of QM or is it derived from something more fundamental? I saw the plank length come up in the Dirac derivation.
I guess I'm looking for some sort of axiom. Something that doesn't follow from anything, but is the lowest level block of QM.
taphead739 t1_j4rn0b7 wrote
It is a natural consequence of the wave-particle duality. If we go back to classical mechanics, angular momentum is present when something moves along a circular path. Very small particles are also waves, and the frequency (number of times the wave function goes up and down per length unit) is a measure for their (angular) momentum. The wave function must now "fit" the circumference - meaning that if you go around the circle the whole 360°, you must end up with the same value of the wave function and are not allowed to have a sudden step. This only works if the circumference is an integer multiple of the wavelength. As a consequence, only certain wavelenghts and frequencies are allowed, and the same is true for angular momentum.
This is a very simplified picture, of course, but I hope it gets the principle across.
luckyluke193 t1_j4xl1v7 wrote
> Is the fact that angular momentum must be quantized a postulate of QM or is it derived from something more fundamental?
Quantisation of angular momentum follows from the mathematical definitions of wave functions and operators in QM. Specifically, it comes from the structure of the group of rotations in 3D, SO(3). In the end, this is Lie group and Lie algebra representation theory.
DragonZnork t1_j4rk8ok wrote
Angular momentum quantization isn’t a postulate, it shows up when solving Schrodinger’s equation for the hydrogen atom.
Speterius OP t1_j4rn6v8 wrote
I'm not sure i get what the Schrodinger equation solutions for the hydrogen atom have to do with the quantum nature of the electric charge.
I understand the electron shells, but how does that relate to the electric field being quantized?
dieEhrevonGrayskull t1_j5vwrq7 wrote
Quantization is a consequence of what happens when waves are bounded. In particular, quantization of energy, and therefore rest mass. Since all of the particles modeled by QM or QFT are done so in terms of wave equations, quantization of the solutions is a natural consequence.
Viewing a single comment thread. View all comments