Viewing a single comment thread. View all comments

AtLeastThisIsntImgur t1_ja6923b wrote

Reply to comment by PregnancyRoulette in Warhammer: I'm surprised how good it is. by PregnancyRoulette

'Dune but Bolt Thrower' makes more sense

13

PregnancyRoulette OP t1_ja69maq wrote

Also solid. The hybrid of swords, guns, genosplicing, psykers is really apt.

8

pelmasaurio t1_ja9ejev wrote

It is not like dune at all, dune's setting is a vehicle for some intelectual heavy lifting, 40k is, as much I have mad love for it, pretty shallow and dumb, ofc it reminds you of dune because is just that, all the dumb things about dune + tolkien stuff thrown in there.

If dune is meat and potatoes, 40k is just the potatoes.

But i will concede you that as far as fanatic legions of super soldiers go, the space marine crusaders leave the freemen yihadists in the dirt.

2

Jamandi_Aldori t1_jaahid3 wrote

>as far as fanatic legions of super soldiers go, the space marine crusaders leave the freemen yihadists in the dirt.

Maybe in a "Vs battle" sense.

As actual characters, the Fremen are far more interesting, both individual and as a group.

Like you said, 40k is shallow and dumb. I love it (I own both the ebooks and physical copies of the entire Gaunt, Eisonhorn, Heresy series, and a ton of other odds and ends, 100+ books)

But even though I love it, it's also dumb. really dumb. Pro-Wrestling-in-space dumb.

1