Comments

You must log in or register to comment.

Wytchfinder_General t1_j9xuy4t wrote

It’s very bleak. Seriously. Imagine standing in the middle of a field at wintertime. It’s cold, snowing and there isn’t a soul around. You haven’t eaten in days and there’s no help coming for you. In fact, there’s no one for miles. That’s The Road.

55

StreetcarZero t1_j9xvhnt wrote

Even worse if there ARE people around like the book.

22

MacSanchez t1_j9xx0sl wrote

Dangit I want to respond to this but don’t want to leave spoilers. I’ll just put my thoughts in a shoebox and put it in the back of my closet somewhere that it can’t hurt anyone.

12

StreetcarZero t1_j9xva1d wrote

It is extremely extremely desolate. I personally love post apocalyptic, survival, prepper - ish stuff but everything I've read before 'The Road' was Sesame Street. Throw out all the cool plot building and factions. Colorful characters with deep back stories and character archs don't exist here. Its a man trying to keep his son alive. There is no real hope. It's prolly the closest I've read to a actual reality and that is what shook me the most. No speeches or grandstanding. No heroic last stands or helping others. Me being a parent, it's the absolute worst case scenario. Terrifying to be honest. I'm glad I read it tho. What people can do and become is more terrifying than anything that can be put in paper. Man o man. Reader beware.

Truly dread. 10/10 would not do it again

33

SnowdriftsOnLakes t1_j9y3rg6 wrote

If there is a better description of this book, I don't know it.

I personally think it's a masterpiece, but it's extremely bleak. Do not read it while depressed as I did. Would not recommend.

8

starspangledxunzi t1_j9z9dvj wrote

I still find it hilarious that it was a Father’s Day selection for Oprah’s Book Club. I mean, the epitome of interns making a recommendation based on the synopsis, without reading the book. Conceptually I get it: it’s a father protecting his child. But I have to imagine an awkward gathering of book club ladies silently staring into their wine glasses, wondering how many others in the discussion group Did Not Finish.

That said, the novel contains magically lyrical passages about being a parent in a dangerous world. There’s no writer like McCarthy.

2

terracottatilefish t1_j9yxrpd wrote

I am so glad I read this book before I had kids because I could appreciate it as the harrowing work of art that it is without really understanding how parenthood would affect my reading. I have kids now, and my oldest is approximately the same age as the boy in the book, and I will never read it again.

2

regencylove t1_j9xvirk wrote

I think it could trigger you. It's remarkably bleak. However its pacey and not that long so you could get through it quickly!

6

Theseus2022 t1_j9y33ox wrote

This book haunts me. It’s a Great Book in the timeless, immortal sense. It’ll be around a long time.

But it is as dark as it gets. I’ve never read anything that comes close to it. It’s credible. One has the sense that this is indeed what the first years of a post apocalyptic future would really look like. It fills you with a unique kind of terror. Dread. Hopelessness. Despair. Fear. It means something more than all of that.

It’s devastating. It’s profound. It’s a masterpiece.

4

Far-Scientist2887 t1_j9y9iwl wrote

An absolute masterpiece.

I’ve have read it twice, brutal and amazing. My wife claims to have ptsd from it.

At your own risk…

4

TheChocolateMelted t1_j9y3c6m wrote

None of the responses so far look at the relationship between the boy and the man. And that is what the book, at its core, is all about. The relationship is quite beautifully depicted. And this is despite - and frequently in response to - the situation they're in.

If you accept the dystopic, post-apocalyptic setting, there are a few pitch-black, horrific events that will probably not go down at all smoothly. I've not read The Stand, and can't really comment about the events in that, but will say that as a writer McCarthy typically has more ability than King to make an event hit you like a ton of bricks.

3

RainbowDMacGyver t1_j9xvo8z wrote

It's bleak. I don't find it particularly realistic but as the other commenter said it doesn't have grand hero plots, it does feel real and hopeless.

I don't know what you mean by triggering. It's not graphic if that's what you mean. Compared to say Octavia Butler.

1

lemewski t1_j9yfhxj wrote

Parable of the Sower was more horrific for me than the Road. It might be that I related to the characters more or felt it was more realistic. That being said, both are on my favorite books list.

3

RainbowDMacGyver t1_j9ygu3t wrote

100% I just read that last month (and the sequel). Completely agree.

Indirect general spoilers**

In The Road >!the climate apocalypse seems to flatten all America into one wasteland with survivors leading somewhat similar lives.!<

In the Sower,

>!there's a sense of unevenness. Certain communities and groups are harder hit, others are sheltered. The way people need to rely on one another even when they can't trust one another. The way different states and cities are affected differently. The role of cops, militias/gangs and community security. THE DENIALISM and normalisation.!<

It was phenomenally detailed and real despite being more of a "sci-fi" work than The Road.

Oryx and Crake is another good one. I read it before reading any Octavia Butler so looking back, I think it owes a lot to Butler.

2

CrazyCatLady108 t1_j9zdnf8 wrote

No plain text spoilers allowed. Please use the format below and reply to this comment once you've made the edit, to have your comment reinstated.

Place >! !< around the text you wish to hide. You will need to do this for each new paragraph. Like this:

&gt;!The Wolf ate Grandma!&lt;

Click to reveal spoiler.

>!The Wolf ate Grandma!<

1

RainbowDMacGyver t1_j9zxcyu wrote

Thank you so much. I'm not sure the content amounts to spoilers as it is general commentary about the contents of each book. However I'm happy to use the text markers just to be safe.

1

CrazyCatLady108 t1_ja005s7 wrote

Good to hear. Unfortunately your markup doesn't work. Remove the spaces around !

1

RainbowDMacGyver t1_ja05z3k wrote

I'm sorry but it seems to work for me? I'm on the Android mobile app and it's working exactly like the example.

1

CrazyCatLady108 t1_ja091f2 wrote

It is a known bug. It looks like it works for you but is plain text for others.

1

RainbowDMacGyver t1_ja0af95 wrote

Ok, thank you for explaining. I don't think there's anything I can do about it so I guess if you need to delete the comment I understand ? In future I will avoid anything that could be considered a spoiler.

1

CrazyCatLady108 t1_ja0cors wrote

All you need to do is remove the spaces around !

Instead of this >! the...lives. !< it should be this &gt;!the...lives.!<

1

TheMattHatter91 t1_j9y9mg7 wrote

Incredible book but can be quite depressing. There is a reason the movie is almost black and white. There is no hope and is a story of true desperation. Some of the thoughts and statements of characters will rattle you if you have any empathy at all.

I love post-apocalyptic stuff but most books make it seem survivable. The Road is much closer to reality and highlights all the challenges of surviving.

1

Mursemannostehoscope t1_j9y9oe7 wrote

I don’t know that it’s triggering, but it did leave me with a sense of wtf did I just read, when I was done.

1

HammerOvGrendel t1_j9y9yby wrote

Not for the fragile. On one hand it's grotesquely violent and at first pass irredeemably grim and truly quite horrible to read. On the other, second-read hand it's still all that but the religious/metaphysical subtext comes out.

1

jamiemarylyn t1_j9ycd86 wrote

So I also get severely depressed and need to stay away from depressing things. I read The Road because it's been highly recommended by multiple people.

I'll say this. It's one of the most depressing books I've ever read (the winner is still A Child Called It) and it for SURE still makes me sad to think about it sometimes.

That being said if you can manage to read it, I highly suggest it. This book is such a good book, and if anyone reads it and doesn't feel sad afterwards then they're not someone who can feel emotions to the same extent. Or they're just REALLY good at compartmentalizing. I got through it by reminding myself "This is fiction. This is fiction. This is fiction" 😅 Good luck! I hope you make the right decision for you, whatever that may be :)

1

The_Upbeat_Jumper OP t1_j9ytge5 wrote

Super glad that you commented that as it puts my mind at ease. I’ve been super intrigued to read it but scared that it’ll trigger a depressive episode if I do 😅 Seeing that a fellow sufferer has managed to get through the novel and still classes it as a good read is enough to convince me. I’ll just have to self-preserve a lot during it and have 10 minute intervals with the dog 😂

Hope life’s easier for you though and thank you for your insight ☺️

1

giraflor t1_j9yfdik wrote

It was devastating for me as a parent who had young kids at the time.

1

Chak-Ek t1_j9ygayh wrote

A better book is The Fourth Horseman by Alan E. Nourse

1

choosinghappinessnow t1_j9ykqzy wrote

I loved The Stand and hated The Road. The Road is extremely depressing.

1

Takemyadviceplease t1_j9yl4gt wrote

McCarthy is an excellent writer. I couldn’t put it down and when I did my teenage son grabbed it and read it. That should tell you something.

1

Ramoncin t1_j9ylpqj wrote

It's far more demanding that anything Stephen King ever wrote. Cormac McCarthy doesn't feel the urge to be entertaining other writers do. However it is a rewarding book. Just not in the way you imagine at this point.

1

echotheborder t1_j9yof8k wrote

It's not very triggering. There's a couple scene that are heavy.

McCarthy trick in the road is creating the post apocalyptic ambience. The relationship between dad and son is really good. It feels like this could happen.

It's a must read imo. But I'm a big fan of post apocalyptic anything.

1

iso_lotus71 t1_j9ytyho wrote

The Road is McCarthy’s most accessible and arguably his best book. Ultimately it has a positive message and moral lessons for father/son relationships. But also there is some deep, dark, scary, shit in it that when subtracted from the post-apocalyptic setting are things that regular people have to face and endure though not in the same circumstances. McCarthy never lets on about how the world got to where it is, it’s all about survival and trust. Is everyone just out for themselves or is there still compassion and unconditional love left in what remains of humanity? I love McCarthy’s older work, my favorite is probably Blood Meridian and/or The Crossing. I’ve read nearly all of his books and I think The Road is his most succinct, most artfully distilled creation. After reading it I was struck by its power for a long time.

1

Kintrap t1_j9ytzhh wrote

Most of these comments make it sound worse than it is.

I wont spoil the plot, but I will spoil something pertaining to a message or moral to the book, so read further at your own risk.

While the content is pretty severe, the ultimate message is pretty positive. You may cry, but you will cry for the depth of the human soul, the love of fellow men, and a glimmer of hope for mankind.

1

Bro_Rida t1_j9ywhpp wrote

“The Stand” comes to a screeching halt once they get to Colorado IMO, “The Road” is great but it definitely doesn’t encapsulate the beginning of “The Stand”. It’s bleak as hell. Themes of suicide, loneliness, giving up, brutality, perseverance.

1

chrispd01 t1_j9yxqx1 wrote

Look. Its a rough read BUT I firmly believe the ending pulls it out. I dont want to give any details but its a toughs slog but worth it

1

HugoNebula t1_j9xxg1i wrote

The Road is quite beautifully written, and about as bleak as you could imagine, but like most 'literary' works dipping their toes into genre, it's a tired and unambitious retread of far lesser known, generally lesser-regarded, but ultimately more satisfying and original works: you could look to Earth Abides, by George R Stewart; A Canticle For Leibowitz, by Walter M Miller Jr; I Am Legend, by Richard Matheson; The Postman, by David Brin; or much of Ballard's early work—The Drowned World, The Drought, The Crystal World.

If you do fancy reading outside of the genre specific, and into literary writers making a better fist of venturing into the post-apocalyptic, you could do worse than Russell Hoban's Riddley Walker, Emily St John Mandel's Station Eleven, PD James' The Children of Men, or Nevil Shute's On The Beach.

0

CrazyCatLady108 t1_j9zawfn wrote

Please post 'Should I read X book''What do I need to know before I read X' questions, in our Weekly Recommendation Thread.

0

HugoNebula t1_j9zb0p6 wrote

Curious how it is that almost every downvoted comment here also contains criticism of—or indifference to—McCarthy's book. Astounding how our supposed literati of intellectual giants seem utterly incapable of engaging in good faith debate or unwilling to defend a criticised work in favour of hit-and-run cowardice.

0

TRIGMILLION t1_j9xx2zt wrote

I pretty much love depressing dystopian type stuff and to be honest I found that book thoroughly boring.

−1

invoinso87 t1_j9yg9h9 wrote

That was my experience as well. Read it when I was in my twenties, maybe worth revisiting after a decade+…

3

sukikov t1_j9yqvoj wrote

I’ve heard it’s a very different read once you’ve had kids.

0

The_Upbeat_Jumper OP t1_j9xxa01 wrote

Could you recommend any good ones?

2

TRIGMILLION t1_j9xxl82 wrote

I'm very fond of Margaret Atwood. Oryx and Crake is great.

2

sukikov t1_j9ysbk9 wrote

Check out these and see if the blurb interests you! I really enjoyed these

The Slynx - Tatyana Tolstaya (actually very funny and satirical)

Before and After - Andrew Shanahan (very different take on the genre)

A female centric one I remember really enjoying was Into the Forest by Jean Heglund

1

Zombiejesus307 t1_j9y382e wrote

When is the word “triggering” going to make an exit from everyday vocabulary? Does anybody know?

−6

gnatsaredancing t1_j9xwbfs wrote

It reads like someone went on a wikipedia spree to just get all the shock schlock from warzones and sieges to string together into the most flat and generic possible "story".

So yeah, if you don't get your jollies reading about the miserable and cruel things we do to each other, it won't be for you.

−10

JoyousDiversion t1_j9xx4qs wrote

Cormac McCarthy going on a Wikipedia spree sounds like one of the least likely things to ever happen

11

gnatsaredancing t1_j9yci7p wrote

I didn't say he did. I said that's how the novel reads. The Road is a tediously bland tale of two people slogging through the most generic possible apocalypse while failing to hold a conversation.

It's a dreary playlist of unimaginative atrocities that ends >!on a silly christmas miracle when the boy is picked up by The Last Nice People on Earth when his dad dies.!<

It's easily the most overrated book I've ever read by far.

1