Viewing a single comment thread. View all comments

wealy OP t1_ixuaek8 wrote

Reply to comment by oridol in So disappointed in The Giver Quartet. by wealy

Funny enough I just taught The Giver to my 8th grade English. We finished like 2 weeks ago which is why i decided to finish reading the series. I had never gotten around to it. Hard pass. Cannot recommend it to students. The original stands alone so well for so many reasons especially the ambiguity of the ending.

3

oridol t1_ixv2tg2 wrote

My 8th grade english teacher never even told us there were more. She praised the ambiguous ending. I wish I remembered more but I moved like 2 weeks after finishing the book so I had bigger fish to fry.

1

jinger_is_a_fundie t1_iydmprb wrote

I actually enjoyed the second book, gathering blue, more than Jonah's story.

1