Viewing a single comment thread. View all comments

wjbc t1_j12k8o6 wrote

Well, Snowball is based on Leon Trotsky, who was exiled from the U.S.S.R. and later assassinated in Mexico City by a Soviet agent. So no, I don't think he is to blame for anything that happens later. I think he was likely killed off screen.

The trial and execution of animals is based on Moscow show trials instigated by Stalin and directed against "Trotskyists." The defendants were widely thought to have confessed under duress, particularly when one defendant repudiated his confession and then changed his mind the next day after suffering a dislocated shoulder and other physical trauma.

So yes, Napoleon is a liar. He's based on Stalin.

128

Jampine t1_j13ereb wrote

Interesting tidbit: the original Animal Farm animated movie was co-funded by the CIA.

Orwell was a socialist, but after seeing how the USSR went, he started writing about how people can twist the goals of communism, and turn it into an authoritatian hellscape.

46

wjbc t1_j13ov1n wrote

Orwell was an anti-Stalinist socialist — essentially a Trotskyist, or at least allied with Trotskyists. He saw what Stalinists were like while fighting Franco in the Spanish Civil War. The Stalinists fought the Trotskyists harder than they fought Franco.

Then Orwell saw millions of Englishmen fall for Stalin after WW2, when times were desperate in England. Orwell was genuinely afraid Stalinists would rise to power in England. And Stalinists did infiltrate the highest levels of government in the U.K. It wasn’t until the Soviet invasion of Hungary in 1956 that public opinion in the U.K. firmly turned against Stalin.

40

BigCommieMachine t1_j145f9q wrote

I think the book is about human nature and how easily power corrupts. You start off with good intention and some power because somebody has got to be in charge. But you keep seeking more power until you forgot what you set out to do in the first place.

It is just more upsetting in communism because at least in capitalism that was the goal in the first place.

9

Joe_Doe1 t1_j16z4l0 wrote

I would agree. They set out to overthrow a tyrannical hierarchy, replacing it with a more just society where all animals are equal. Soon, they become tyrannical themselves, and a new hierarchy develops where some animals are more equal than others.

People see it as pessimistic, but I see it as realistic.

4

Great_Hamster t1_j1bx7wc wrote

The goal in capitalism is freedom from feudalist and mercantilist restrictions on trade and profession. Where you getting this other thing?

2

ithsoc t1_j14wuog wrote

> the original Animal Farm animated movie was co-funded by the CIA.

Tons of literature was funded and directed by the CIA beginning in the early 1950s.

The CIA were some of the principal orchestrators of the entire Iowa Writers Workshop program that steered literature away from material concepts and into a more postmodern framework where objectivity was not valued and individualistic feelings were centered.

4

bonanbeb t1_j138jd9 wrote

This is interesting, I also finished the book but wasn't aware it was mirroring historic events. So, did Molly actually leave or was she likely killed too?

5

JamJarre t1_j13s810 wrote

The rabbit hole runs deep with the historical parallels in this book.

Characters:

  • Boxer is the working class, betrayed by the pigs / Stalin. He does everything he's meant to do loyally but they still turn him into glue

  • The four "young pigs" who are killed are likely the top soviets killed during Stalin's Great Purge (Bukharin is the only one I remember)

  • Mr Jones is Tsar Nicholas

  • Mollie, the horse who leaves because she can no longer get ribbons and sugar cubes, represents the Russian aristocracy who fled after the Revolution

  • Moses, with his fairytale talk of "sugarcandy mountain" is the Russian Orthodox Church

  • Napoleon's pack of dogs are the KGB

  • Old Major is Lenin, whose ideals were corrupted by his successor Napoleon (Stalin). As mentioned in another comment, Snowball is Trotsky - driven out for ideological differences and later turned into an enemy of the state

  • The neighbouring farms are the Western powers. Frederick is Hitler - a leader who initially seems aligned with the farm but, it turns out, is betraying it (in real life Operation Barbarossa, in the book the fake money). Pilkington is probably Churchill.

  • Mr Whymper is a bit harder, but I think likely to be the kind of useful idiots / tankies that helped spread the soviet agenda in Western countries during the Cold War

Events:

  • The hens refusing to give up their eggs is the Ukrainian revolt against collectivism

  • The windmill represents Stalin's "five year plan", along with its subsequent failure that leads to famine.

  • The Order of the Green Banner is the Order of Lenin

  • Frederick / Hitler's attack on the farm is the German invasion of Russia in WW2. It's repulsed, bloodily, just like the USSR threw back the Nazis in places like Stalingrad and Leningrad

The only one I never worked out is the cat. She talks about the revolution supportively but doesn't do any work, and is later found to be playing both sides. I'm not sure if she represents a specific person, or a class.

55

wjbc t1_j140wxd wrote

The cat represents the portion of the Russian upper class, intelligentsia, and bureaucracy that survived the revolution by pretending to support it. She was pampered by the Empire and would prefer to return to the old regime, but she’s an expert at manipulation and deception so she survives in the new regime.

28

bonanbeb t1_j13tgyu wrote

Wow, this is so comprehensive. Thank you, it really shows the book in a truer light.

9

Alwayssunnyinarizona t1_j141j57 wrote

This book needs a sequel. I'm not knowledgeable enough about Russian history ~1950-1990 to write it, but it sure seems like the ghost of Napoleon has returned.

6

The_Chums_of_Chance t1_j13b6ut wrote

She leaves. She doesn't want to give up her comforts. It mirrors the bourgeoisie, who fled Russia after the Revolution.

20

wjbc t1_j13pej5 wrote

1984 imagines an English form of Stalinism. But Animal Farm is a direct allegory of Stalin’s rise to power in Russia.

7