My disappointment with Daisy Jones and the Six

Submitted by tootifr t3_10on72j in books

I’ve gotten back into reading after a few years of not picking up a book. Today I finished a book in a day but I still felt underwhelmed by the end of Daisy Jones and the Six.

At first, the writing style seemed intriguing and I like the choppiness of switching between characters. After a while though, it felt like lazy writing but I stuck through it for the entertaining aspect of the book (I won’t say plot because there wasn’t much of one). Just when I began to like a character or find out more about them, the focus went back to Billy and Daisy - yes this was probably the point and highlights the dynamic of the band but it was like the author wrote this knowing it would be adapted into a show.

Lastly, the breakup of the band was built up from the very start of the book and it was just anti climatic! The storyline was cliche and the dysfunctional-star-of-their-day-who-actually-feels-lonely is overdone. It’s not new and there was nothing exciting about it but I stuck with it, hoping it would get better. I liked finding out who was narrating/interviewing but that’s about it. I might give the show a chance but it does seem like something which has been done before.

17

Comments

You must log in or register to comment.

Known_Study3560 t1_j6g6dsp wrote

I really liked it but I listened to it on audiobook. Different actors read each character. It was very entertaining. Maybe I would not have Loved it if I read it.

16

Nizamark t1_j6gg7m1 wrote

started strong but i didn’t love where it went. i appreciated its ambition though.

3

Own_Book_1102 t1_j6gjak9 wrote

I listened to the audiobook and enjoying the writing style. It was so different and great listening to with a full cast. I had high hopes for it, but I agree with you that it was disappointing. It was definitely anticlimactic. I was hoping for a better ending.

4

blueberry-scones101 t1_j6gkpn1 wrote

i just don't think taylor jenkins reid books are for me. i listened to the audiobooks and although it enchanced the experience of the book and i didn't care for the characters in the end and daisy annoyed me the most (i really wanted to like her in the beginning but ¯_(ツ)_/¯)

9

it-was-a-calzone t1_j6h7ksm wrote

This was a DNF for me- I think as other commenters suggest I would have liked it better on audiobook but as it was I suppose I felt as if I’d rather actually read a behind-the-scenes of a real band, since like you said, it seemed to just be using cliches from real stories of bands and I wasn’t particularly invested in any of the characters.

6

honestlyicba t1_j6hnbux wrote

This is one of those rare books I enjoyed immensely on audiobook and drifted off with text.

2

Ineffable7980x t1_j6huy3o wrote

Have you ever watched an episode of VH1's Behind the Music? It was a documentary series that was very popular in the 90s. I don't know for sure, but I would bet money that Reid was inspired by it, because this book felt like an extended episode of it. As such, I experienced quite a bit of nostalgia as I was reading this and therefore loved it. But my larger point is I don't think it was lazy writing at all. I think what she was doing was very intentional.

2

missing1102 t1_j6ievf1 wrote

Book was hot garbage. The pov was written by somebody who did very little research about musicians. The characters were lifeless, the dialog was flat. In my case, it was reading somebody's very poor draft of a book.

2