Both controller are fine, id use either one. The issue is the shit parts they use to make them. I cannot tell you how many times I’ve had stick drift on PS3, PS4, XBOX360, XBOX One, and series S controllers. The only one it hasn’t happened with is a PS5 cause I never ended up buying one. That shit is so infuriating. Every year I have to get a new controller because of stick drift. And I only play a few hours a day maybe, I’m not excessively using my controller more than I should. It’s bullshit

Edit: forget to mention sometimes the controllers just break, button inputs don’t work, the vibrators fall out of place. The plastic will crack. Obviously it’s not every single controller but I’ve had it happen to at least one or two for each generation of console I’ve had, PS3 was probably the worst