Comments

You must log in or register to comment.

leftyavfc1 t1_iz4hbh5 wrote

Switch would be a good introduction to gaming. And you can’t go wrong with Mario kart.

7

Prestigious-Mine-513 OP t1_iz4in2l wrote

Replying to leftyavfc1 (#870,855)

Im on the fence between Xbox and Switch, but the only game I can think of is as you mentioned Mario Kart for switch are there many other games suitable for the younger kids?

Xbox had me interested as it has Minecraft and Roblox which also are hugely popular games for young kids.

4

Qempic t1_iz4kacy wrote

I voted before i realized that its for 5- years old lol

6

leftyavfc1 t1_iz4lq7t wrote

Replying to Prestigious-Mine-513 (#870,908)

In my opinion the Xbox’s value for money proposition is excellent and arguably unrivalled when it comes to Xbox Games Pass. For a low monthly fee you have an unbelievable choice of top games to play and they’re updated all the time.

The Switch I still feel though would be better suited for the age range you’re talking about. Being able to play it on the go in the car etc (hopefully they share! Although something to consider on the flip side, maybe it’s good for a console to stay at home if you don’t want them playing too much) , and I feel like the games themselves are more tailored to that age.

Alongside Mario Kart there’s the likes of Pokémon, Luigi’s Mansion, Paw Patrol, Super Mario World, Minecraft, splatoon, donkey kong, Mario tennis, sonic, Zelda, the Lego games, Spyro, the list goes on.

3

Flimsy_Quiet_7246 t1_iz4rtaa wrote

Switch has more E rated games compared to xbox and playstation, which are suited for a more mature audience

3

OppaiNoKamiii t1_iz4yiwi wrote

For a 5 and 6 years old? Non. Buy them normal toys not videogames.

1

leftyavfc1 t1_iz4yvtt wrote

Replying to Prestigious-Mine-513 (#871,657)

It comes included with a controller or you can slide the sides out and it can be used as two joy sticks. You could probably just start with that and then see if another full size control would be useful down the line.

2

Prestigious-Mine-513 OP t1_iz4yy51 wrote

Seems like Nintendo Switch is the way to go judging by the overwhelming votes for that age group.

I will have to check out the S series, but thus far it's probably ending on the Switch if not convinced otherwise.

Is the switch considered to be a console and can be a stationary box connected to the TV without a problem which was in my mind. Or is it considered a handheld? If the handheld console would be connected to the TV at all times would it reduce its lifetime?

Suggestion on extras? Would 4 controllers be a minimum requirement for 2 players?

What's the average price of the games on the switch?

Appreciate all the replies guys! 👍👍👍

4

dude35_ t1_iz51w9t wrote

I think the switch is good for introducing them into gaming and then if they decide they want to get more into gaming the Xbox series S would probably be the best option for an actual console :)

2

JamesMackenzie1234 t1_iz5ak4x wrote

Replying to Prestigious-Mine-513 (#870,908)

I would say switch, I had Nintendo in the past and now have xbox. The switch has a lot more games for kids their ago and when they are older you can get them an xbox in how ever many years and the switch doesn't have very many tiles that aren't appropriate for there ago were as the xbox does. They both have mincraft and sure the xbox does have roblox but the switch had all the different Mario games. In the end the switch is more appropriate for their age but the xbox is more future proof.

3

Mccobsta t1_iz5g4ta wrote

Nintendo has a much more family friendly atmosphere to it

Lock it down don't add any payment methods to it set up a child account

2

Sammelquest t1_iz5x0h0 wrote

Replying to Prestigious-Mine-513 (#871,628)

I actually have to really discourage from mine craft on switch specifically. It runs REALLY REALLY BAD. Barely playable. But I still think the switch would be best for a kid. The first party lineup and many indie games are great but I'd check performance reviews for third party stuff before buying it. Especially for car rides and on the go in general the switch is best.

2

SilentJoe1986 t1_iz63uc3 wrote

Which one has the most durable and easiest to clean controller?

1

Yoshbit t1_iz66bi0 wrote

It's the least expensive option and if they break it, you can just buy them a new one as it's not as expensive as the others.

2

high_tier_kill t1_iz6epfq wrote

Since nearly all so called legendary games on ps4-5 are 18+ and switch is pretty limited I'd say Xbox.

2

YNG4eva t1_iz6iy14 wrote

Outside ffs

−1

capncook84 t1_iz6ln9y wrote

For sure Nintendo switch. If you and your parter intend to use it, then you van see one of the thousands of "Playstation vs Xbox" debates online for more information, but yeah, for sure switch for the >13 range (not to say that you wouldn't enjoy the switch also, just that the games you choose to get on it probably wouldn't be much enjoyment to you)

2

SicTim t1_iz6xg1q wrote

Replying to capncook84 (#874,166)

I'm 60 and "Mario Kart 8" is my jam. Literally fun for all ages.

I own a WiiU, haven't upgraded to Switch (partially because so many early Switch releases were updated WiiU games), but I can also vouch for "Splatoon," which is the most fun I've had with a shooter since "Battleld 1942," and I also hear good things about the sequels. It can range from casual ("Turf War") to extremely competitive (ranked play).

Also, there are very limited communication options, so no toxic behavior to worry about.

Finally, I bought "Smash Brothers" because I was told my young niece and nephew absolutely loved it, but it wasn't for me.

Anyway, Nintendo has always been a kid-friendly brand, plus the Switch is the least expensive option.

3

APBG_Oficial2 t1_iz76d2s wrote

nintendo switch is good for starting and here is why: No blood Kids games like racing (Mario Kart), fun with family (Mario Party) and a lot others

2

Freya_almighty t1_iz77ifq wrote

None. A five years old should be playing with physical toys and play outside….

I’m get downvoted so much for saying. But it is what is

2

Shiny_Buns t1_iz7bdz8 wrote

My 6 year old nephew loves his Nintendo switch. He always wants me to play Mario cart and switch sports with him lol

2

giantsoftheartic t1_iz7cbbl wrote

Replying to Prestigious-Mine-513 (#871,715)

My switch is heavily used hand held and connected to TV, and I have owned it over a year now . It is working great, and the battery is still great. It looks fantastic on the TV, and it is worth buying for Legend of Zelda Breath of the Wild alone.

Add to that the fact Zelda Tears of the Kingdom releases 2023 and the new OLED switch has released it is a great time to be buying a Switch.

I only have one controller, and I've had no complaints. Animal Crossing New Horizons can be played 2 players with half a controller each, and when playing one player, it can be attached to a base controller to give a PlayStation controller type feel sort of.

I'm a PS4 and Switch owner.

3

JustVGames t1_iz7ezzc wrote

get them a NES mini. Next year get them a classic SNES mini.

1

Hurkamur t1_iz7nyaq wrote

If you get the switch, be sure to get a screen protector and a case. As long as it's on the dock through the TV you should be fine. Portable mode + a 5 year old sounds like a recipe for a busted console.

2

spoonard t1_iz7rg9f wrote

Switch is great when little kids step on it and break the screen, lose the controllers, and cough and sneeze fluids all over the screen when using it. /s

The Switch is NOT for kids that age unless it's put up away from them and they are using a couple of pro controllers. And since that's the way that would be safest for them and the console, you may as well spend less money and get a used PS4 and an extra controller and really guage their interest

2

B0BS_UR_UNCLE t1_iz80vxk wrote

Maybe when they're 10. They're only little and fun for such a small amount of time. Give their imaginations a fighting chance.

2

RaspberryNo8592 t1_iz8k4nb wrote

Dont give them any my little brother of 7 years old had a switch since he had 3-4 years old and he almost never gets out of it he looks like a teenager on his phone but watching paw patrol or play fortnite all day long on his nintendo switch and my father's ps5 so in my opinion dont give anything electronic related to a very young kid

2

Jaymodillio t1_iz8oofm wrote

Switch will die if repeatedly dropped, absolutely great console, but the good games hold their price so are not cheap. It would have to remain docked.... may as well get an xbox and game pass is incredibly good. I have three kids I had a switch early on, which they totally appropriated, they all prefer Xbox.

1

NG_Gambit t1_iz8yhqb wrote

Get the switch and move up to the Xbox in a couple years. Nintendo easily has the most child friendly game library, and the portability is good for kids as they won't be hogging the TV all the time + can take it to their mates gaff and play it in the car or whatever.

Xbox is great and game pass is fantastic, with a decent library of kid friendly games. but for a five year old... switch is without a doubt the way to go.

PlayStation's demographic is casual adult gamers. They have some great exclusives, but not much child friendly stuff deffinately not the right choice here

Also I saw you talking about Minecraft, I've not got a switch and someone says it doesnt run great, but you can always Bluetooth a controller to a tablet or phone and play that way (or with touch controls if you really want). In my experience Minecraft can run on anything bar a toaster so I'm surprised switch has issues. Regardless. There are plenty of ways to play Minecraft, and save files and realms (personal servers) should work fine across all devices as long as you are signed into your Xbox account 👍

2

TechnicalPlantain459 t1_iz98qmk wrote

Series S slaps, I've had this Xbox S for ages and it's still going strong, albeit it sometimes lags a bit on YouTube and very occasionally turns off. Also some games are pretty laggy even Minecraft is laggy but only laggy when I'm near big structures/builds or near alot of mobs lol...but I've had this Xbox for ages now I reckon 5 years or so and the updates are great too..I really like when they change the look of the side bar options and just over all Xbox visual look is cool too.

1

Prestigious-Mine-513 OP t1_izd3mzb wrote

Thanks for every reply on tips, hints, suggestions and recommendations.

😉👍

1