alnyland t1_ja9nsex wrote on February 27, 2023 at 9:29 PM

Reply to comment by phiwong in ELI5: What is the fastest way to stop a car with a manual gearbox ? by navenarf

Right, but engine braking reduces the excess energy leftover once the tires would start skidding, and in my experience can decrease it enough to be below the point where skidding would begin. I drive in snow a lot and use this frequently to decrease speed, not to stop.

In the instances I mentioned, I started with engine breaking then switched to brakes once at a slower speed - my brakes were fine.

Bensemus t1_ja9pvqs wrote on February 27, 2023 at 9:42 PM

> engine braking reduces the excess energy leftover once the tires would start skidding,

This sentence makes no sense. The wheels have a certain amount of grip. That doesn't' change depending on how the car is being slowed down. If you are skidding you've exceeded the wheel's grip.

To control speed both brakes or engine braking work. To emergency stop engine braking offers nothing.

DasMotorsheep t1_ja9v5fg wrote on February 27, 2023 at 10:16 PM

>Right, but engine braking reduces the excess energy leftover once the tires would start skidding,

Again, it doesn't. Think about where the energy for revving up your engine comes from when you're engine braking... It's the wheels rotating against the road, which via the driveshafts make the gears in your gearbox rotate, which via the clutch will turn your engine over.

If you have a motorbike, you can try this out relatively easily - apply rear brake until just before you lock the rear wheel, and then downshift. You'll see that your rear wheel will lock. It has happened to me.