Viewing a single comment thread. View all comments

rasa2013 t1_iuh22a9 wrote

There's a lot of things that can spontaneously kill anyone. Random blood clot in the wrong place, for example. And old age predisposes you to having those kinds of events and also not recovering from those kinds of events.

E.g., say an otherwise healthy person gets an active heart attack. Some people, for unknown reasons, their heart will try to power through the problem and keep pumping. It hurts and is not good obviously, but it could buy them time to get treatment. But strangely, some people's hearts will encounter this problem and just stop functioning. We don't really know why every time. It's partly genetic luck though.

Otherwise, death is usually from a chronic condition of some kind, not entirely unexpected. It's a process. You don't just die all at once. Your body exhausts itself slowly building from the primary chronic problem, like a bad liver. And it's in your sleep because eventually, your body doesn't have the resources to actually keep your brain fully conscious.

For example, my grandma was around for two weeks after we all agreed to stop the main healthcare and go for hospice instead. She was awake and "fine" in the beginning. no real bad pain or anything. You wouldn't know just from looking at her that she was dying. we could chat. But she no longer felt hunger and her body didn't really produce waste normally. as the time went on, she spent more time asleep. And eventually she didn't wake up much at all.

3

Seeker_Of_Knowledge- t1_iuha9fl wrote

The inconsistency man. You said "we don't know why" and then in the next second you said "it is partly genetic luck".

−3

Upper-Wolf6040 t1_iuhi5hu wrote

He said "we don't really know why every time, Its partly genetic luck".

The key words are "every time" and "partly"

1

Seeker_Of_Knowledge- t1_iuhii99 wrote

And this is exactly why I said inconsistency.

If it one time a genetic and the other time it is not genetic. Then it is clearly shouldn't be taken as a reliable data. Hell, it shouldn't be even taken as assumption.

1

ixramuffin t1_iuhkhrj wrote

Medicine deals with averages. We rarely know what is happening to individuals. Saying that "something is partly genetic" and "we don't know why every time" are not exclusive at all. On average, genetics has an influence. We just usually don't know "when" and "for whom".

2

Seeker_Of_Knowledge- t1_iuk2tv5 wrote

Oh I see the point. Thanks, it now make sense.

Medicine deals with averages is super interesting concept I haven't thought about before.

1

Upper-Wolf6040 t1_iuhjf61 wrote

That still doesn't make sense. They're not saying one time is genetic and the other time is not genetic. I think youre misinterpreting what they're saying.

0

rasa2013 t1_iuieeeb wrote

That's an interesting interpretation. Genetics plays a role, but we don't know the specifics. We just know it's involved. Ergo, we don't really know why.

1