Comments

You must log in or register to comment.

epalms t1_iugs7e8 wrote

It could be done, however due to sheer numbers it would be a catastrophic strain on the environment. Can you imagine if 700+ million people just started cutting down trees in order to heat their home all winter? That coupled with the fact that most homes are not equipped with any heat source outside of the natural gas/electric furnace they were built with.

18

RIP_Sinners t1_iugt6cn wrote

Medieval Europeans did a lot of dying in the winter. Old people, very young people...

A lot of the winter survival tricks are either not viable or no longer worth it. The solutions of today are better, it's just a matter of getting enough consensus, in most cases.

18

deep_sea2 t1_iugx9ig wrote

It's odd how some people don't get this. OP is basically asking, "Why can't modern people just accept a life expectancy of 40 years and an infant mortality rate of 300 death per 1000 births."

People back in the day were tough, but it's not like they were good at surviving. People have sucked at surviving right up until the 20th century.

8

Luckbot t1_iugrvny wrote

Laws and investments.

Medieval people survived the cold by making fire inside their homes, today you have to fulfill regulations to do that (I.E. you need a proper fireplace and chimney). Just adding those to an existing home can be expensive, and at least in my area they are pretty much sold out.

In medieval times population was much lower, so it was viable to just heat every home with wood. If you tried that now we'd run out of forests quickly, and dense cities would be dark in the smoke

8

mfb- t1_iugs5e6 wrote

Improved living standards, too. What was normal 500 years ago won't be accepted today.

6

LifeScienceInvestor t1_iuif58o wrote

You can if you live on a farm and have a fireplace or a wood-buring stove. However,

  • there are more people today than in medieval times;
  • they are packed into cities;
  • those dwellings do not typically permit the burning of coal or wood for heat (they use modern gas-fired forced air and steam heating systems, most of which also require electricity to operate);
  • the wood consumption for the population would require significant deforestation, even if everyone had a wood-buring stove (which they do not);

So, you can't use medieval heating methods (burning wood) in densly packed cities whose dwellings aren't designed to burn wood for heat.

3

thebestnames t1_iuiigu8 wrote

Pretty hard to fetch branches in the woods at the back when -

  1. There is no wood, since you live in a city and cutting down park trees would get you arrested.

  2. You don't have a fireplace to begin with, so you can't legally and safely warm yourself with a fire.

3

mousicle t1_iui9bn1 wrote

Modern apartments don't have fireplaces and chimneys to safely have fires to warm your house. The people of Germany and Ukraine didn't spend all summer and fall cutting down trees and storing firewood for the winter. Medieval Europe's economy basically completely shut down in the winter.

2