Viewing a single comment thread. View all comments

Devil-sAdvocate t1_ja5ztty wrote

Reply to comment by ManannanMacLir74 in 4,500-year-old Sumerian temple dedicated to mighty thunder god discovered in Iraq. by Rifletree

Link a peer reviewed scientific written paper, anyone can make a random video.

10

ManannanMacLir74 t1_ja6078g wrote

What?If your going to discuss an academic level YouTube channel then we have nothing further to discuss and peer review means absolutely nothing

−4

ManannanMacLir74 t1_ja60fbc wrote

You're going to parrot peer review yet more than a few scientific studies and papers have exposed the flaws in it and argue it's ineffective nature.

Do you want those studies or papers too?

−10

MisterFistYourSister t1_ja6bl7q wrote

Why does your video carry more weight than peer review?

9

ManannanMacLir74 t1_ja6hwvc wrote

Peer review isn't really reliable but it's still used so why would I refer back to a flawed method?

−4