It's been a while since I've eaten at Wonder Bagel, but when I lived in DTJC (now in JSQ), I absolutely loved Wonder Bagel and would eat there once or twice a week. But, you need to make sure you a bagel that's recently out of the oven. If you get a stale bagel, it'll be bleh. If you get your bagel toasted, that's your fault and on you.

I was particularly a fan of their whole wheat bagels. Chewy deliciousness.

I have no idea how it's these days though.