DEPENDS on the repair.

It has to look professional and safe. And metal around it solid.

Booger welds, and welding 1/8th" plate to a unitbody 18 gauge sheet metal in a crumble zone, would be a fail.

Booger welds on a frame (body on frame) and repair questionable . will = fail.

So is the repair questionable? if so you kinda know the answer.