You didn't mention if you wanted to be close to one of your hometowns, so here's an app that shows what places are reachable within one hour drive of each: https://app.traveltime.com/search/0-lng=-72.61516&0-tt=60&0-color=%23d60064&0-mode=driving&0-title=Agawam%2C%20Hampden%20County%2C%20Massachusetts%2C%20United%20States&0-lat=42.06886&1-lng=-71.12866&1-tt=60&1-mode=driving&1-title=Somerset%2C%20Bristol%20County%2C%20Massachusetts%2C%20United%20States&1-lat=41.76955 (zoom out to see better).

Basically, no overlap between the two. However, something close to the mid-point is the Charlton/Sturbridge area, which itself is very nice.

If you're OK with a longer drive to your hometown, a place like Wilbraham describes what you're looking for pretty well.

All that said though, you'll probably get some better results if you provide more info like if you have a job in a particular location and commute is a factor, etc.