Viewing a single comment thread. View all comments

netrate OP t1_jdtemr1 wrote

Reply to comment by TeamStark31 in Knock at the Cabin Door questions - spoilers by netrate

I guess that still doesn't make sense to me. If they don't die, they don't have to make the choice. It was emotional blackmail.

2

TeamStark31 t1_jdtepwx wrote

Essentially yes, but it was showing them their choices had consequences.

It probably shouldn’t make sense to non cult people, although the ending shows they were right.

2

TeamStark31 t1_jdthbfl wrote

Leonard also says once the four of them are dead and they didn’t make their choice it would be too late to stop it.

However >!Eric killed himself, which Leonard said wouldn’t be enough, and everything stops. This suggests he was lying, or at least adding his own details.!<

1

dont__hate t1_jdw6jbn wrote

I think Eric's partner killed him. He didn't kill himself.

6

TeamStark31 t1_jdwz5c7 wrote

It happens offscreen, but Eric believed and said he would do it as Andrew was the non believer.

Also, either way it was still after all the horsemen were dead, so it shouldn’t have worked but it seems like it did, so Leonard was also still lying about that.

0