Comments

You must log in or register to comment.

Badwolf_131 t1_it1nbmv wrote

iTunes does it. Purchase the movie, download it, then the file is yours. It has a signature in it that makes it only usable by you. Before my external HD blew up that’s what I do with my movies. That way I could just travel with that and not have to bog down my laptop with a fuck ton of files.

9

HumOfEvil t1_it1nbpt wrote

Because everything is now wrapped up in all sorts of legalese which means it's not legal to download and keep them.

Digital copies are essentially long term rentals.

There are exceptions but I think that's generally the case.

3

LuinAelin t1_it1nc4q wrote

It is a piracy measure. Make it harder for you to share the movie

3

Spaghetti_Noodle1 t1_it1np11 wrote

I refuse to buy digital copies of movies from Amazon after hearing about people losing access to them, I still buy a Blu-ray copy whenever I want to keep a movie.

8

ScaryProfessional711 OP t1_it1o62e wrote

Do you actually own a universal file though? Can you play it through windows media player or is it only playable through itunes approved player? I've never used iTunes so I'm unfamiliar. Amazon allows for downloads but it's downloaded to their app that you install on your device so it's still tied to Amazon. You can't play the downloaded movie through any other media player.

1

Infamous_Yogurt2858 t1_it1oaza wrote

Put simply, because when you buy a copy of a movie, you're not actually legally buying the copy but a license to view it. That's pretty much moot when it comes to a physical copy, but in the digital era, the rubber is meeting the road in that respect.

2

ScaryProfessional711 OP t1_it1opy2 wrote

That's why I was asking about downloading movies vs downloading music. Downloading music is allowed but movies are not. Are they going to eventually make music the same way where music is basically just rented and listened to thru the media player of whatever platform you purchased it from and we will no longer be allowed to own any music files, movie files, video games, etc. Is this to be the future where you own nothing and only rent it until the platform you rented from or the creator decides they no longer want to rent it to you? Then you're SOL

2

Badwolf_131 t1_it1pkx6 wrote

Didn’t try using anything beyond QuickTime. But it is downloaded in a folder on the computer as an MP4. So theoretically it should work. On that computer. Or any other computer that has authorizations through your iTunes. Theoretically.

It’s been some time since my external blew up. So I haven’t been able to use this option since.

0

ASK_IF_IM_PENGUIN t1_it1r5a1 wrote

It very much varies by jurisdiction as well.

In the UK it is technically illegal to transfer media between formats, so you technically can't to CDs, DVDs, or Blu Rays.

That's exactly what I do however. I buy my movies as physical media, and rip them to my NAS. That way I've always got a physical copy, but the convenience of a digital one as well. And I've paid for it.

2

TheRealClose t1_it1r672 wrote

Don’t all Blu-Rays still come with a digital code to download the film?

I’ve never used that as I have used iTunes for years. Very conveniently get all my movies automatically downloaded onto my hard drive.

2

raptors661 t1_it1somy wrote

They did at one point in time in the early days, but now it's just for whatever the current movie streaming thing is. Ultraviolet or whatever. You can easily rip a Blu-ray though. Takes 20 min

2

raptors661 t1_it1sxqt wrote

I believe they had a download option, but they called it offline mode where you would download a file but it's an encrypted file not like an mp4 video file. I could be hazy on my memory though

1

GlassMuffin2286 t1_it1tthy wrote

Digital codes kind of tried to adress it, but it was too fractured between services to really catch on for the average person. I've given away countless digital codes for that reason. They also expire which is a problem for older releases. In addition, they're not immune to licences being pulled or services being merged/shutdown.

Aside from being an anti piracy measure I think it's also to keep the customers in their ecosystem. Once the customer loads up the app/software to view digital purchases they'll likely be presented with other content to rent/purchase at some point during navigation.

As to why music DRM is less intense, anyone's guess is as good as mine. I suspect it might be that audio files are accessed and moved more often between devices. If the DRM was too hardcore it could become a hindrance and possibly impact sales.

There's a rough road ahead for this kind of stuff I think. Acquisitions and rights being transferred around will result in content being pulled from services, or outright removed from personal digital collections as we've seen a few times already.

1

Pjoernrachzarck t1_it1uv63 wrote

You never own software. Even if you download a file, you’re purchasing a licence to use the data, you don’t ‘own’ it. And it is in the publishers legal right to disable the file you downloaded remotely.

So the ‘difference’ to streaming you’re talking about, apart from possibly convenience, is an illusion.

2

Jar_of_Cats t1_it1v2kx wrote

I think it will be the best use for NFTs. I only buy digital content. I own none of them

−3

thecrabbitrabbit t1_it1xxyt wrote

The studios don't want you to be able to copy your downloaded movie to a USB stick/plex server/etc and share it with your friends and family. They want everyone to buy their own copies.

Music companies were forced to allow DRM free music downloads because there was a big consumer demand to be able to e.g buy a song from iTunes and play it on a Nokia phone, but now the market has moved to mostly streaming and you can easily stream on any device that demand has gone. People who are concerned about actually owning their movies are a declining niche that the studios can ignore.

1

IWishIHavent t1_it20g28 wrote

You can download the movies you purchase on Apple's iTunes Store. The content is tied to your AppleID, though, so you can't simply move the file around and duplicating it doesn't work.

There's probably a way to remove the protections, but I never checked.

But, on that note, you might want to check Jeff Geerling's channel on YouTube. He posted a video last week about owning your media and he explains how he started ripping discs to have his movies in the computer - and even stream it, though only inside his own network.

1

Twigling t1_it249xd wrote

I fully agree with what you say. And regarding this part:

> I read online that Warner Bros planned to start phasing out DVDs and blurays this year in the process of going completely digital.

One thing worth noting is that when you stream a movie (or TV show) it's very heavily compressed.

With Blu-rays (for example) there is still some compression but the video and audio quality is still a lot higher and because of this the data takes up a lot more space - the average movie is usually somewhere between 30 to 40GBytes on a standard Blu-ray, while 4K will of course be even larger.

If studios start going down the 'streaming only' route (so no physical media at all) you can bet they'll still use very heavy compression; this wouldn't be so bad if they let people legally download purchased content using the same kind of compression that your average movie on Blu-ray is subjected to, but you can bet your bottom dollar that this likely won't happen, or if it does it will be on a very limited scale.

Using the above example digital only is bad if you want the best audio and visual quality, even more so if you have a large 4K TV.

And then of course you have movies that are stuck in 'streaming only jail' - two examples of this are the war movie 'Greyhound' starring Tom Hanks and the excellent Christmas animated movie 'Klaus'. The former is stuck with Apple TV+ and the latter with Netflix. I'd love to buy these on Blu-ray but I can't. There's piracy of course (which I don't indulge in) but even then the pirated versions will only be rips from the lower quality streams.

The customer is losing out, as so often happens.

2

ScaryProfessional711 OP t1_it2e481 wrote

The problem with ripping discs is once they stop making movies on disc and go completely digital you no longer have access to new movies unless you go the rental route which is what it seems these studios are wanting.

1

Fantastic-Watch8177 t1_it2eulh wrote

Capitalism strikes fear.

But look, if you already bought the film, why would downloading a copy for personal use be illegal? My understanding is that copying itself isn’t illegal; breaking DRM is.

I don’t believe any prosecutor would even try to go to court if it’s a download of something you already bought.

1

ScaryProfessional711 OP t1_it4kyq3 wrote

It's actually cheaper. I'm currently buying up copies of animated movies because I have newborn nieces and nephews that will start watching them in the next couple of years. I pick up the discs on ebay used for $2-$5 on average. I checked Amazon and the same movies on Amazon are $3.99 to rent and $15-$20 to purchase. Physical media is cheaper and then you can just make digital copies for the kids to watch and keep the discs in a binder as backups.

1