Viewing a single comment thread. View all comments

5abbingia t1_iujqc6i wrote

As pointed out by others, I believe it is generational. As adaptations of the original material they are barely passable, and despite being amazing in some aspects (cinematography, effects etc) they are mediocre in others (mostly writing and dialogues). (imho)

−1

banghi t1_iujt5ai wrote

>As adaptations of the original material they are barely passable

Most folks haven't read the source material and have no perspective to base their views on. In a world of hobbits be a Tom Bombadil...

3