Viewing a single comment thread. View all comments

To_The_Past t1_iuhob85 wrote

Reply to comment by No-Tune-868 in How to watch and analyse arthouse cinema? by lonzosch

Same only applies here in the absolute broadest strokes (like plot, lots of good and bad films with the same basic plots). How they develop and explore that theme is tremendously important to the film you get, in virtually every aspect of the film, and there are also other variables as well as theme.

Replace the basic themes in Blade Runner and you simply don't get Blade Runner. You get something completely different.

A lot of shit films have the same type of editing as good movies too, that's just a fact too. Doesn't mean editing isn't critically important to the movies you like working as they do.

3

No-Tune-868 t1_iuhonay wrote

Then ur proving my point. I didnt disagree with how themes are explored affects quality. I disagreed that themes affect quality.

And of course if u replace themes ud get a different movie.

0

To_The_Past t1_iuhp7gl wrote

>I didnt disagree with how themes are explored affect quality. I disagreed that themes affect quality.

I disagree that this is a meaningful distinction, let alone one that I proved. You said you're not sure themes are important - bad movies have the same basic themes as good movies, after all! My contention is that they are, and that bad movies have them too is a bad argument.

Bad movies often have the same basic editing or plotting as good movies too, but this doesn't mean editing or plotting are unimportant, that's a bad argument. Editing, plotting - and themes - and getting them right in the execution of a movie - are crucially important. Even if they're not the tangible things that jump out to you as why you liked the movie, they are crucially important factors that resulted in that end.

2

No-Tune-868 t1_iuhq2vu wrote

Yeah i read what u said last time. No need to repeat urself.

Im still right and ur still moving away from the point onto editing and blah blah blah.

Sophistry at best.

1

To_The_Past t1_iuixe0z wrote

I don't think you understand what either me or yourself are saying. Editing is used as an analogy that illustrates why your argument doesn't make sense. You're not right, you have decided that you have to be right but are unable to articulate your position coherently and have it withstand any scrutiny, and this is frustrating you. Have a nice day.

2