Viewing a single comment thread. View all comments

cookiemagnate t1_j25b2q9 wrote

5 point system for the following categories:

  • Directing
  • Cinematography
  • Performance
  • Writing
  • Music

Find the average

+1/-1

  • If I feel like they succeeded or failed in their Genre
  • If I feel like they succeeded or failed in their intent

For instance, just watch Del Toro's Pinnocchio

  • Directing: 4/5
  • Cinematography: 5/5
  • Performance: 4/5
  • Writing: 3/5
  • Music: 2/5

Average = 3.6

+1 for Animated Fantasy

+1 for intent

Total 5.6 out of 7

Where:

  • 0 = Should be forgotten
  • 1 = Terrible
  • 2 = Meh
  • 3 = Fine
  • 4 = Good
  • 5 = Great
  • 6 = Excellent
  • 7 = Masterpiece

(Edited for formatting)

1

5thInferno OP t1_j25c1xn wrote

Wow that’s quite the system

1

cookiemagnate t1_j25doza wrote

It's fun! I've gotten some surprising results breaking down movies like this.

I'll also use this to rank movies within their Genre, mainly to give B-movies more recognition.

Like Velocipastor overall is a 3/7 with a major boost in genre and intent. But looking solely at it through a genre lens, Velocipastor is a 5.4/7

1