brewski t1_jc7x7ab wrote on March 14, 2023 at 6:12 PM

Reply to comment by DrewSharpvsTodd in What are some good NY style pizza spots in Hamden, CT area? by loper6989

Surprised to see that opinion by a "pizza snob".I've eaten there plenty since my kids seem to like the ambiance. Respectable pizza. Out in any Midwestern suburb it would be far and above the best pizza for hundreds of miles. But around here, it's probably like #20 on my list. Behind Mangia, Olde World, Odie's, Eli's, Ernie's, Zuppardi's, Dayton St, even Da Legna.

DrewSharpvsTodd t1_jc854x0 wrote on March 14, 2023 at 7:02 PM

Eli’s is shit lmao. What are you talking about.

brewski t1_jc89gr6 wrote on March 15, 2023 at 12:31 AM

You are the only adult I know who rates Paul and Eddie's as anything better than average for this region. Eli's took over the historic Bimonte's place and didn't change much. It's not top tier but I'll take it over Paul and Eddie's any day or the week. Cheese, sauce, crust. Better in every respect.