Submitted by Fancy_Fig_3959 t3_yd7pa6 in newjersey

Hello everyone,

We're planning to move to New Jersey in coming month. I have few questions,

  1. Which particular area in Bloomfield or Montclair are safe for a family to live?
  2. How's the commute from Bloomfield or Montclair to midtown?
  3. Is there any tax apart from State tax?

Thanks all in advance.

0

Comments

You must log in or register to comment.

NippleIsland t1_itqk90k wrote

I loved renting in Montclair, things to note is to make sure where you are renting has dedicated parking. Parking is a serious, serious issue in Montclair. It's the top reason I moved, next to the ridiculous rent prices. Regarding safety, Montclair is weird where you can be in a safe area walk a street over, and not have the same warm feeling. I cant speak much about Bloomfield. Welcome to the area!

2

Fancy_Fig_3959 OP t1_itqp5nk wrote

I saw that when we were roaming around the area, and I was confused that's why I asked here....thanks for sharing

2

throwaway2343576 t1_itqmcm7 wrote

The commute into the city from either is fine.

There is a state income tax and sales tax. Be prepared to have your mind blown when you see what the real estate taxes and rents are.

I personally love Montclair. The shops, the restaurants, the medical care quality and availability (Yea Summit Medical Group!), the Wellmont Theater, the selection of wellness and self-care services ... It's lovely, and very walkable.

2

Fancy_Fig_3959 OP t1_itqq0qy wrote

Have already experienced the blown mind :) I though moving a bit away will reduce the price but man I was wrong! It's all same!

3

5uck3rpunch t1_itqfyfn wrote

Montclair & Bloomfield have good & bad areas of both. I personally would choose Montclair because IMHO I thinks it's a nicer town. They are similar commutes because they border one another. Check out Little Falls, which is next to Upper Montclair. That is where I grew up (I live in Dallas now) & I would suggest that to anyone.

1

Fancy_Fig_3959 OP t1_itqizdf wrote

Okay...thanks! We're moving from Austin. I hope you like Texas lol!

0

5uck3rpunch t1_itqkyq1 wrote

It's decent when it's not triple digits up here in DFW! Lotsa luck in NJ. It's very diverse there & easy to go see other states nearby for the weekend! Enjoy being near the ocean also! I miss that!

0

LateNightNewYork t1_itqjj9u wrote

Both are good for families, just depends on how much money you have as Montclair is more expensive.

1

Fancy_Fig_3959 OP t1_itqk4k7 wrote

Okay thnaks....Money I don't have much lol! Any idea about Income Tax thing?

1

res_mps3 t1_itqmz6l wrote

Aside from state and fed tax no other tax that I’m aware of.

No tax on food or clothes btw.

Everything else is around 7% sales tax, I think cars were 6.23% (probably off by a bit).

If you’re living up north I hope you have above average money at the least haha

1

111110100101 t1_itqqppt wrote

If you live off the montclair-boonton line you will have a direct train into penn station NY, it’s a very doable commute. I would try to live within walking distance from the station as having to drive & park at the station will just add more stress.

Montclair is a beautiful town but it’s gotten extremely expensive. There aren’t really any dangerous parts of town but generally south of Bloomfield Ave is less nice.

Bloomfield is cheaper but some parts are sketchy, specifically the downtown area around Bloomfield Ave. It’s a block by block thing so hard to say without visiting the area for yourself.

If you live in NJ and work in NYC you will be paying NY State income tax and probably zero NJ tax (since the taxes you pay to NY get credited off your NJ tax bill).

1

ElderberryExternal99 t1_itqzts5 wrote

Just a suggestion talk to a real estate agent in those areas. You might find a hidden gem in those areas.

1

kurt667 t1_itrelpu wrote

so you're thinking the part of montclair where the homes are only 1.5 mill might be a bit slummy???? lol....

1

Fancy_Fig_3959 OP t1_itrnajz wrote

If I could afford a 1.5 million home I would not be asking this question, this was about the affordable areas.

3

ReadenReply t1_itrfc02 wrote

There are several new/newish apartment complexes that include parking along the Montclair-Booton Line in redeveloped stations areas at Bay St Station in Montclair, Bloomfield station and Watsessing Station (also Bloomfield)

1

thebruns t1_itqqcyj wrote

These seem like common questions that a cursory search could have answered

0

Fancy_Fig_3959 OP t1_itrnpmh wrote

Yes I agree and I've already done that, this was just to the know the experience of ppl living there/already lived there

2