Viewing a single comment thread. View all comments

Blenderx06 t1_iy6r6f1 wrote

Reply to comment by humorous_ in Accused barn arsonist’s plea agreement rejected by judge by Swiggy1957

Amish are hardworking but they have very high rates of domestic, child sexual, and animal abuse in their communities which they keep hidden. They should not be put on pedestals.

Obviously this is not to condone what this person did in any way.

14

Hfhghnfdsfg t1_iy7igsn wrote

Also in many Amish communities, the men have agreed that they should be able to use some modern tools, but no modern tools are allowed that would make women's work easier.

6

humorous_ t1_iy6yvby wrote

That’s fair, but you can say that about any number of communities. For example, police have a domestic abuse rate of 40% (4x national average for USA).

I wasn’t really trying to put the amish/mennonite communities on a pedestal as much as I was their craftsmanship and work ethic. I think any community, sufficiently insular, will have bad actor-members who exploit the insular and secret nature of the group to their own ends. Doubly so for any religious community.

5