Viewing a single comment thread. View all comments

thought_first t1_j6intz2 wrote

> allegations the social media giant abused its dominant position to monetise users’ personal data

That is their entire business model. Not sure what they are defending against here.

90

1QAte4 t1_j6j0j97 wrote

This is the business model of most social media companies and I don't know what the alternative would be except making people pay subscriptions to use sites.

19

Borninthewagon t1_j6jqhya wrote

Not a business expert, but I don't believe you need to gather and sell people's personal data in order to sell advertising on your site.

24

Aazadan t1_j6jydka wrote

You don’t, but to generate targeted ad’s as well as content feedback loops which in turn get you more targeted ad’s does require personal data.

2

PsecretPseudonym t1_j6o1kds wrote

Nope. Content-based targeting (e.g., AdWords, originally) doesn’t need to know anything about the user.

2

Aazadan t1_j6o97y0 wrote

Which is a completely different type of targeting. That’s targeting people based on a product they’re looking at not something like “show this ad, to men between 30 and 40, who have gotten a car repair within the past 60 days”.

1

PsecretPseudonym t1_j6pcdam wrote

Yes, “different type of targeting” means you can still do targeting. Just not user-specific targeting. In many situations contextual targeting is actually far more effective (e.g., search ads have performed incredibly well even prior to much use of personal user info/history, because keywords searched at the time of search represent by far the most valuable piece of information to select the highest expected value ad).

2

DeNoodle t1_j6jwv6h wrote

But to make money from selling advertising on your site you do.

−3

Detachabl_e t1_j6kgaw0 wrote

It's not the monetization, it's the abuse of it's dominant position. In other words, there should be 5 or 6 little facebooks all vying for our data.

6

1QAte4 t1_j6kl3dl wrote

There are a bunch of different companies doing personalized ads. Google, Twitter, TikTok all use different data to personalize ads.

1